The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 223 contributions
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Thank you very much, Dr Simon Gill—that has been another tremendous presentation.
Colleagues, that concludes the public business for today. Our next meeting will be next week on Tuesday 8 September, when we will take evidence on AI and its potential impact on Scotland’s economy. We will now move into private session to discuss agenda item 3.
10:58
Meeting continued in private until 11:23.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Welcome, everyone, to the second meeting in 2026 of the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee. We have received no apologies. I would remind members that they do not need to operate their own microphones, as they will be operated for them during the public part of the meeting.
Agenda item 1 is a decision on taking business in private. Do members agree to take item 3, which is consideration of our work programme, in private?
Members indicated agreement.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
I am cognisant of time, so I will move on to Rachael Hamilton. Just before I do, I can see my Falkirk MSP colleagues gritting their teeth a little bit. This is a specific point, but I just want to highlight that it was the Grangemouth refinery that closed, which is just one part of the Grangemouth facility. The world-class petrochemical plant is very much still running.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
I appreciate those detailed answers, which are really helpful, but I am cognisant of time. We have time for probably one or two more questions. If we run out of time, might we be able to send you some written questions?
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Thanks, Dieter. Noting that we have gone past your cut-off of 9.45, I thank you for your time. That has been a tremendous overview of energy with, perhaps, some hard truths spelled out. If we have some questions, perhaps we can forward them to you.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Colleagues, we will have a short break as we wait for the next speaker.
09:47
Meeting suspended.
09:53
On resuming—
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
I am cognisant of the time and the need to keep things moving. I call Gary Bouse.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Before I bring Daniel Johnson in, I have a quick question of clarification on pumped storage. What size of capacity are those projects? I note those that are going ahead off Loch Ness, for example.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Sorry—I have another question of clarification. If you are talking about a 1GW project and 10 GWh, are you saying that you get the 1GW for 10 hours?
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee
Meeting date: 1 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Do colleagues have any more questions?
I have one. Dieter Helm talked about the system costs of our energy system. To a certain extent, you are talking about the same thing, but what differentiates your position is that you think that some of those system costs can be overcome through the use of hydrogen and so on. Is that a fair representation of the difference in view?