The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 223 contributions
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
I thank the minister and his officials for their time, and I suspend the meeting to allow them to leave.
11:49
Meeting suspended.
11:50
On resuming—
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Our next meeting will be on Tuesday 6 October, when we will take evidence as part of our pre-budget scrutiny and discuss our work programme and the budget.
That completes our business for today.
Meeting closed at 11:51.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Thank you very much. I appreciate the opening remarks.
I will start with a general question before I bring in members. We had evidence sessions last week. The witnesses were broadly supportive of some of the themes in the programme for government, but Professor Stuart McIntyre from the Fraser of Allander Institute called it a
“cluttered landscape of economic strategies”.
Stephen Boyd of the Institute for Public Policy Research Scotland shared that sentiment, saying that there is
“no credible, coherent economic strategy … that stakeholders can unite behind.”—[Official Report, Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee, 22 September 2026; c 13, 14.]
In particular, he thought that there was a lack of clarity and consistency.
We can see in the programme for government a huge number of new agencies, new units, new programmes and new funds. For example, AI Scotland is set out as a flagship international programme. We have a Scottish Government bond programme, a high-growth unit, a major projects office, a Scottish innovation fund, regulatory sandboxes, knowledge transfer partnerships and empowered regional economic partnerships.
There is a lot going on there. Reading that, it is hard to escape the view that it is a cluttered environment. It is hard to see what the timelines and specifics are for getting those organisations or programmes up and running. That all seems to be set against the backdrop of public sector reform, whereby we seem to be consolidating various bodies, from the national health service to councils. Here, we seem to be doing the opposite and introducing many new bodies and programmes. What would you say in response to those comments?
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
I guess it is a question of delivery as much as anything else. There are many new bodies, programmes and so on. How will you deliver them in a timely and measurable manner so that people can see progress? Everyone can see that the things that I listed are useful in themselves, but when we bring them all together it is hard to escape the criticism that there is a cluttered landscape. What would you say to that criticism?
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
I have a supplementary question on heat networks. I am aware of a heat network operating in Aberdeen. How do we get behind the sheer scale of capital investment that is required? That will involve entering homes and massive retrofit costs in places such as Edinburgh, which has a significant number of tenements, and Aberdeen, where there are old granite buildings.
It is very difficult to do these retrofit jobs. How do you see heat networks interacting with that? How are you getting your arms around the sheer capital costs that are required?
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Just the good half.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Thank you for that brief answer. [Laughter.]
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Before I open up the discussion to colleagues, I have one further, connected question. It is kind of on the positive side as well. Last week, we heard evidence from Professor Paul de Leeuw of the Robert Gordon University Energy Transition Institute who highlighted the job destruction that we are seeing in the oil and gas industry. It is fairly well known that that is on a certain trajectory. Some of the projects that are being discussed would help, but the trajectory remains downward.
It is a case of “A bird in hand is worth two in the bush.” The minister foresees jobs coming through from renewables, but the scale, timing and location of those jobs is not clear. It is subject to forecasts and perhaps variability, especially in the case of floating offshore wind, which has cost challenges.
How do you see those challenges, and what are your comments on that?
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Members have no points to make, so I invite the minister to wind up.
Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 29 September 2026
Duncan Massey
Before we move on to different topics, I will ask a quick supplementary question. You talked about the cost savings per capital investment. It is almost like a creaming curve that we might use in the oil industry to understand what the best investment is.
Do you try to grade and review the measures? For example, there is a lot of evidence that if people adjust their existing gas boilers to adjust to weather, so that the boiler is on at the right times or at lower temperatures, it can have a huge impact. Do you look at that versus what we are talking about here, which is capital investment to improve insulation or to move to different devices, for example? Do you have that sort of analysis?