Plenary,

Meeting date: Thursday, May 7, 2009

Official Report 780KB pdf

---

Presiding Officers Rulings

I will respond to the points of order that were raised earlier today, as I promised to do.

Regarding Margo MacDonalds point of order, I have studied the transcript carefully and, while I am absolutely satisfied that Mr Grays remarks were not aimed at any individual in particular, I take this opportunity to remind all members that the words "lies", "lying" or "liar" should not be used in this chamber in relation to other members—and preferably not at all.

Regarding Mr McConnells point of order, having studied the transcript very carefully I can rule only that it is not a point of order for me and it is therefore not a matter on which I can rule; I can only advise Mr McConnell that, if he wishes to pursue the matter further, he should take it up directly with the First Minister.