Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Standards Committee, 12 Mar 2003

Meeting date: Wednesday, March 12, 2003


Contents


Annual Report

We have only one item on the agenda today, which is a draft annual report, as required by standing order 12.9. Members should have seen a copy. Are there any comments on the report?

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton (Lothians) (Con):

I have one. I am content with everything in the report, but paragraph 9 on page 2 states that the Scottish Parliamentary Standards Commissioner Bill provides for "mandatory registration". I argued for voluntary registration. Is it possible to enter "subject to the reservation of one member"?

The Convener:

We agreed on the draft bill. The sentence that you quote gives a factual statement. The report is a factual account of what we have already agreed. Your comments will be noted in the Official Report, which certainly can be read as an appendix.

Tricia Marwick (Mid Scotland and Fife) (SNP):

Paragraph 11 on page 3 is about meetings. It is quite right that the committee records how many times it met in private, but we need to say that, when we are dealing with complaints against members, although we consider draft reports in private, our deliberations are done in public and our findings are made public. I recognise that the report is factual, but we need to stress that our inquiries on MSPs were conducted not behind closed doors, but in public.

I think that we can agree to that. The clerks will add that.

Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab):

I have a separate and minor point on cross-party groups, which are mentioned on page 2. I have expressed my hope at previous meetings that the issue of cross-party groups will be taken up actively and speedily by the new committee and the new Parliament. To reinforce that point, rather than saying,

"Both will help form a revised and robust framework",

we could indicate that the matter is not done and dusted and that work still has to be done.

That is a fair point.

We will e-mail the amended report to members so that we have a final report before we sign it off.

Meeting closed at 12:58.