The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 36 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
Mr Castro, in your opening statement, you talked about international comparators, but the fact is that many countries that have had wealth taxes have ditched them, because they end up being counter-productive. You also talked about the Nordic countries having higher tax rates, which is correct, although I believe that, in those countries, they get many benefits back, particularly in relation to fuel costs. I wonder whether you have got your data correct on how people will react to such measures.
Ms Walker, do you really think that middle-income earners who can now change their working hours quite easily under new employment legislation are going to wear these tax increases, particularly given that we are probably looking at high inflation next year? From a political perspective, I really do not think that any party would be particularly happy about making these moves.
11:45
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
I would argue that, in the Nordic countries, people are supported across the board. Everyone benefits, for example, by getting money back to help with their fuel costs. In this country, we spend money on free prescriptions, although I think that a lot of people would be prepared to pay for them themselves. It is things like that that concern me.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
Is that taxpayers, are you aware?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
That is clearly a crucial question for us.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
How big a factor is crime in the retail sector businesses that you represent?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
There is a lot of evidence out there that the kids who are routinely playing truant are the ones who are getting into crime, and they are then the ones who do not enter the labour market. I think that we should do a lot more to identify those kids and help them at that stage. That would take them out of the criminal justice system, which would be good, because that area is cash strapped as well. What do you think about integrating something like that into what you have suggested?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
Okay. I have a quick question about preventative spend.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
You would advocate a progressive system that could be evaluated with specific outcomes to see how it was working for the economy as a whole.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
Mr Borland, you represent small businesses. If I was sitting in a board meeting and looking at the risk registers of many of those businesses, what main challenges would I see, and what would be the highest risks?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Kim Schmulian
Mr Begbie, you mentioned student loans briefly. Since the introduction of student loans in Scotland, have they prevented people from going into entry-level jobs? I am an advocate of lifting the rate at which people start paying tax. Is that another factor?
I have personal knowledge of a number of kids who were at school with my sons who, having come through university and looked at their student loan and at the likelihood of getting on to the housing ladder given what they would be able to earn at entry level in Scotland, went to Australia. How much of an impact has that had? Should we have retained the old grant system? Would we be better off now if we had done that?