The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 21 contributions
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
You talk about your unique demographic challenges. Is there more than average demand for the visiting hospital eye service in the Western Isles than there is elsewhere?
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
So what will it be doing? Where will it be going?
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
Is your position that your new charter is far more profitable for you than the previous routes were?
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
Looking at the wider context, your multiyear contract for transporting energy workers was announced on 30 April; on 1 June, you launched a new route to Paris; and on 20 June, you launched a new flight to Bordeaux. If I were an islander seeing lifeline services being reduced in that context—at the same time as you are expanding your services overseas and announcing that you now have a contract for energy workers—I would be pretty angry. Do you understand why island communities feel so strongly about this issue, when you have reported rather large profits in your most recent accounts?
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
I completely appreciate that engagement of that type prior to a decision is not a normal thing for a commercial company to do, but I agree with the point that Mr Ghani made about the fact that it would have given the communities more time to look at those services—indeed, I put it to you that those are not normal routes but lifeline services for those communities.
You talked about a funding model. You would surely agree that advising and engaging with HIAL and the Government earlier, prior to the decision being made, would have given them more time to work with you on a solution.
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
Thanks for that. It is particularly worrying that you have had no engagement with the airline about those issues.
Mr McKinnon made a point about engagement. I want to bring in the Shetland Islands Council and ask what engagement you have had with Loganair.
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
I want to come back in on the back of Collette Stevenson’s question and the points that Maggie Sandison and Martin Joyce made around the need for a wider discussion about Highlands and Islands connectivity. I would probably agree that that is needed.
There certainly seem to be countries, particularly in Europe, that do this far, far better than we do, and we need only to look north to the Faroe Islands to see an example of that. When it comes to future engagement with the Government and the private sector, should there be a role for international comparators and looking at the different models that different countries have in place for island connectivity, given that they seem to do it better and have better outcomes than we do?
I am happy for either Maggie or Martin to pick that one up.
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
The scale of the mitigation means that it cannot all be covered.
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
Has that limited your exposure?
Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Lloyd Melville
Thank you for your indulgence, convener. Mr McNamara, you have just said that you accept that you could have done more earlier to engage particularly with the NHS and affected communities. Will your approach be different for future changes? Will you engage, explain the scale of the problem that you have and ask how you could make the situation work?