The Committee agreed to undertake some further work on what minimum core obligations would mean in practice. This work was to build on our previous work on human rights budgeting and help provide context ahead of the introduction of the proposed Scottish Human Rights Bill.
'Minimum core', in the context of human rights, is intended to be a baseline of social, economic and cultural rights that every state should implement immediately.
They are responsibilities related to economic, social and cultural rights which a country needs to comply with at all times and in all circumstances, regardless of their resources or the overall conditions of a country.
The UK signed up to follow the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) in 1976. Scotland, as a devolved nation of the UK, has an obligation to ensure it complies with ICESCR to so that the country can meet its obligations. These include the right to an adequate standard of living, housing, healthcare, education and work. Examples of minimum core are:
If the government does not provide rights to a minimum core level, it is in violation of its legal obligations.
The Scottish Government originally announced it would introduce a new Human Rights Bill during Session 6.
It was anticipated that the Bill would:
At previous evidence sessions the Committee heard Scotland should have a participatory process to define what minimum core means for the country. We’ve also heard from some witnesses that minimum core in Scotland should aim to ensure that a person can live with human dignity.
The proposed Bill has since been delayed, with the Scottish Government publishing a discussion paper on 1 July 2025 by way of an update.
Minimum core obligations were discussed at the following Committee meetings:
The Committee has sent and received the following correspondence during the inquiry:
Supplementary evidence provided by Professor Katie Boyle on minimum core obligations, 31 May 2023
Supplementary evidence provided by the Scottish Human Rights Commission, 21 April 2023