To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will publish the statement given to the media in response to allegations reported in Scottish newspapers on the conduct of the Crown Agent in handling evidence at the Lockerbie trial.
On 17 July 2009, Christine Grahame MSP issued a press release highlighting unfounded allegations she had made to Lothian and Borders Police. These allegations have subsequently been dismissed by the police as having no basis.
To help with questions from the media about Ms Grahame''s press release, the following note to editors was provided:
We have been made aware of serious allegations made by Christine Grahame against the Crown Agent, Norman McFadyen, in relation to the Lockerbie trial.
These are defamatory and entirely unfounded allegations of the most serious kind. Norman McFadyen is a man of the utmost integrity who is held in the highest regard by the Law Officers.
Not only is the allegation false in itself, but Mrs Grahame appears to have misunderstood the process because the documents which she has referred to were not part of and had absolutely nothing to do with it.
The whole process was fully considered by the trial court which thanked the then Lord Advocate for the Crown''s efforts to bring as much information as possible before the court. By the end of the process, information made available to the Crown by the US authorities was made available to the defence, the trial court and also the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission in the form in which it was received from the US authorities.
The commission extensively and fully investigated the process. The commission concluded that there was no basis to refer the issue to the appeal court.