To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S1W-3886 by Susan Deacon on 21 March 2000, when it plans to increase total health spending to the current European average as a percentage of national income.
The following table shows public expenditure on health as a proportion of GDP in Scotland and in countries within the European Community in 1997 - the latest year for which comparable data are available.
Public Expenditure on Health as Percentage of GDP |
Country | % |
Germany | 8.3 |
Sweden | 7.2 |
France | 7.1 |
Belgium | 6.7 |
Denmark | 6.7 |
Luxembourg | 6.4 |
Netherlands | 6.2 |
Austria | 6.0 |
United Kingdom | 5.8 |
Finland | 5.7 |
Spain | 5.6 |
Italy | 5.3 |
Greece | 5.0 |
Ireland | 4.9 |
Portugal | 4.7 |
EU Average | 6.5 |
Scotland | 6.4 |
Notes:
1. The source of the data for European countries is the OECD healthcare database 1999. The estimate for Scotland is based on total NHS expenditure and an estimate of GDP at market prices.
2. OECD estimates of health expenditure as a percentage of GDP use GDP at market prices. Although this figure is available for the UK, separate estimates are not made of GDP at market prices for regions within the UK. To obtain a figure for GDP at market prices in Scotland the following method has been used: it has been assumed that the Scottish share of UK GDP at market prices (Including North Sea oil output) is the same as the share of GDP at factor cost. It should be noted that estimates of UK GDP at market prices may be subject to revision and this would affect the estimate of Scottish GDP at market prices.
3. The EU average has been estimated by weighting together the figures for individual European countries, with each country's GDP used as the relative weight.
4. Private expenditure on healthcare is excluded from these figures.
Expenditure on the NHS in Scotland in 1997 was about the same percentage as the EU average although comparisons of health expenditure between countries should be treated with considerable caution. There are differences between countries in methods of organising and delivering healthcare as well as differences in funding arrangements. There may also be differences in methods of recording expenditure on healthcare and, as the OECD point out, "the very definition of healthcare...differs from country to country". All of these factors may distort comparisons between countries.
The Scottish Executive is committed to making substantial increases in health spending for the duration of this Parliament. As tangible evidence of this, health spending in the current year has been increased by almost £500 million on last year's planned level of funding and is due to increase by a further £2.095 billion by 2002-03. This represents a significant investment in the NHS in Scotland and the Executive is now working with the service to ensure that the resources are invested effectively in a way that will deliver sustainable improvements for patients across Scotland.