Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 22 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 46 contributions

|

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Outdoor Access in Scotland

Meeting date: 18 November 2026

Finlay Carson

My question is specifically for Stuart Chalmers. Stuart, you talked about visitor safety and restricting access. I know, anecdotally, that the Forestry Commission had been developing visitor access for years, whether through the 7stanes mountain biking centres, the new visitor centre at Kirroughtree or whatever. However, it appears that far less of that work is now being carried out, and far less investment is being made by Forestry and Land Scotland, which is not doing very much to enable responsible access.

During Covid, Fergus Ewing reduced the restrictions on motorhomes using Forestry and Land Scotland car parks. Indeed, he encouraged that activity, and there were fewer restrictions than there are on commercially run campsites. Has investment in visitor facilities on Forestry and Land Scotland land increased? Similarly, has the number of full-time-equivalent employees involved in visitor access increased over time, in line with more people being encouraged into the countryside? In short, has Forestry and Land Scotland increased investment to enable responsible access?

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Outdoor Access in Scotland

Meeting date: 18 November 2026

Finlay Carson

I will put this question on resources specifically to Philip Waite, from Highland Council. Are we just underresourced? In earlier evidence, we heard that Forestry and Land Scotland has reduced its resources for public access. We also heard about the Government removing funding that had been ring fenced for rangers. We do not have the funding for core paths. What part does the lack of resources play in people not being allowed to access the countryside responsibly?

Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee [Draft]

Cross-party Groups

Meeting date: 5 November 2026

Finlay Carson

We have Confor involved, which is a major partner. The idea behind the budget is to ensure that the group reaches out. Many different businesses are involved, starting with the horticulturists that grow the plugs for the tree plants. The budget is intended to ensure that we achieve that wide reach and generate as much cross-sector interest and awareness as possible.

Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee [Draft]

Cross-party Groups

Meeting date: 5 November 2026

Finlay Carson

Good morning, colleagues. Yes, the proposed cross-party group is on forestry and wood processing industries, not food on this occasion, although that is very important to the same areas of Scotland as forestry is.

I thank the committee for considering the CPG application. I believe that the proposal meets the criteria and the tests.

Forestry and wood processing industries are of significant importance to Scotland’s economy and environment, and they are also of social importance to Scotland. They support thousands of jobs and underpin investment in many rural communities, they contribute to sustainable construction and manufacturing, and they play a vital role in achieving Scotland’s ambitions on biodiversity enhancement, climate resilience and net zero.

Many of the issues that affect the sector cut across ministerial portfolios and parliamentary committees, which means that there is value in providing a dedicated forum where parliamentarians and stakeholders can come together to exchange views, identify challenges and explore opportunities.

It is important that I set out to the committee that the proposal did not start from scratch; it builds on the excellent work that was undertaken by the previous cross-party group on the wood panel industry, which was convened by Fergus Ewing. That group, which was well attended, demonstrated the value of parliamentary engagement with the sector and showed that there is an appetite among stakeholders for constructive dialogue. The group also raised awareness of the importance of the industry across the Parliament by highlighting the opportunities and challenges that wood processing industries face.

However, the challenges, as we know, extend well beyond the wood panel industry alone, so the proposed group intends to broaden its remit considerably by bringing together the forestry sector, timber growers, wood processors, manufacturers, construction industries and wider stakeholders to examine the full forestry and wood value chain.

The intention is to look not only at commercial forestry and timber production but at the role of native woodland and woodland management in supporting biodiversity. I am pleased that Scottish Woodlands and the Woodland Trust have indicated their support for the group.

By adopting that wider perspective, the group would be a more comprehensive forum for discussion on what shapes forestry and the industries that depend on it.

I would be delighted to take any questions.

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Outdoor Access

Meeting date: 4 November 2026

Finlay Carson

I am conscious that other members will want to ask about how the code can keep pace with things, but my question is this: did it set out to create a culture? After all, if that is what you are doing, you do not have to be specific about whether it is responsible to, say, take a motorbike into a peat bog or have a barbecue. It is about the whole culture instead of its being directed at one specific thing. Has the code been successful in creating that culture?

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Outdoor Access

Meeting date: 4 November 2026

Finlay Carson

Yes. My question goes back to the point about culture. We have been talking about byelaws and legislation. We are legislators, and we sometimes try to prevent legislation from coming in, but a lot of the time it is just there.

There is a question about when the right and wrong time is to have a barbecue. In Galloway, we just do not have barbecues at certain times of the year. Supposing there were a byelaw that said that we were not allowed to have a fire between, say, 1 September and 10 November, it might still not be sensible to have a barbecue on another date if it was dry or there were different conditions.

We also talked about being prescriptive and not having lists in legislation about what people can and cannot do, because, as soon as we do that, we end up excluding something or taking away people’s responsibility to make a judgment. We keep talking about how people should take nothing from nature but photographs, leave nothing but footprints, kill nothing but time, and that sort of thing. Should we not be developing that kind of culture rather than saying we need to ban this or not allow that?

I am thinking about when there were rangers—before the Government took away the ring-fenced funding for them, which led to the number of rangers falling off a cliff because local authorities decided to spend their money on something else. It was not the case that the rangers had lots of powers to enforce legislation; that cannot possibly be done, because, even in the best world, there would not be enough rangers.

Should we not focus on the culture rather than on byelaws that specify when people can and cannot do things? We could develop a culture in which people take responsibility and think about whether it is sensible to start a fire or to go off-road with their mountain bike. That is what we should concentrate on in any refresh of the legislation.

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Outdoor Access

Meeting date: 4 November 2026

Finlay Carson

We have somewhat moved on from the point that I was going to make, but I am not sure that the outdoor access code played a role in the development of culture. Twenty-one years ago, a different cohort of people accessed our countryside. As Professor Higgins touched on, it is about responsible citizenship and whether we need a code. Being a responsible citizen as you go into the countryside is no different from being a responsible citizen when you walk down Sauchiehall Street, for example, in relation to the dumping of toilet waste or whatever.

Is it not the case that Governments do not like legislation that reviews or revisits things? However, there has been considerable change after 21 years. It is not that the code is not right any more, but some bits need to be clarified. Foil barbecues were probably not sold for £2 in every shop 21 years ago, we now have drones and more motorised vehicles and camper vans, and Covid resulted in a huge increase in the number of dogs that people have. Is it more about ensuring that there are regular reviews to address some of our modern issues? That would also have a role in raising awareness.

To what extent has the code worked? It could be argued that it worked and continues to work, but any code needs to be refreshed regularly.

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Land Reform

Meeting date: 28 October 2026

Finlay Carson

Can I just ask, when it comes to—

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Land Reform

Meeting date: 28 October 2026

Finlay Carson

We have covered a lot in the past 15 to 20 minutes. Something that stands out to me is that voluntary negotiation partnership tends to work better than when legislation kicks in and forces sales or whatever. We heard about the Church of Scotland dumping churches on communities. Maybe we should also look at the impact of the Royal Bank of Scotland and the Bank of Scotland dumping buildings on our high streets. We cannot ignore that, but do we need a review of what has been done to see where we have had successes and failures?

In Dumfries and Galloway, we have great community trusts. They bought a lot of assets because capital funding was available, but, I am sad to say, they have been failing within a few years because the revenue capacity does not exist within communities and they have not hit critical mass. Do we need to review that, to see whether we need to change the land fund and make a significant amount of revenue funding available for pump-priming, to get over the initial costs?

I will give an example. We have a fantastic state-of-the-art bunkhouse. It takes time to build up the customer base, but, during that time, you have to pay your manager £40,000 a year and the revenue is not coming in. Does the land fund need to focus not only on capital purchases but on pump-priming initial set-up costs and covering the revenue in order to make such organisations successful in the long term?

Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]

Land Reform

Meeting date: 28 October 2026

Finlay Carson

Here we go again. When I first stood to be an MSP, my predecessor, Alex Fergusson, said to me, “There are two things you want to avoid: deer management and land reform.” I am into my third session and, sadly, once again, we have a Government that seems to be obsessed with land reform—we are seeing it again.

As Hamish Trench said, we did a significant piece of work on land reform last year. Surely we should be spending the next few years ensuring that legislation is implemented in the best way to deliver outcomes.

When it comes to outcomes, should we really be measuring success by who owns the land or in terms of changing ownership patterns from large to small? In some people’s book, it appears to be a measure of success if there is change. However, surely it should be about delivering outcomes, particularly when public attitudes suggest that healthcare, housing, economic growth and the cost of living always outrank land reform as priorities. Should we be focusing on who owns the land or on ensuring that our farms and estates deliver the outcomes that we want as a population?