The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 46 contributions
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
From what we are hearing, there seems to be some conflict. The witnesses on the previous panel said that some of the legislation should be black and white and that we need national guidance, but Kenny Auld has suggested that that is not necessary and that issues should be dealt with case by case. If we start bringing in byelaws and additional legislation, is there a risk of being too prescriptive instead of expecting people to make a judgment about what is or is not responsible?
I am hearing from this panel that we need a refresh of the Scottish outdoor access code, to update the language and reflect the culture that we are now in, 21 years on, but that we do not need a full review. Is that what you are all saying?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
My first question is for Peter Rawcliffe. In your written evidence, you suggested that, initially, between 2005 and 2010, the bulk of the resourcing of your work was based on raising awareness of the code, which was done through television adverts and so on; then from 2010 until 2020—a decade—that focus shifted into encouraging people into our natural environment, to promote the benefits of access to the countryside; then, from Covid onwards, there was again more focus on the code. Did that focus arise as a result of too much focus having been put on getting people into the countryside rather than giving equal importance to their viewing that access—that right to roam—in the light of their responsibilities? Did we get the balance wrong for that decade—which has resulted, I believe, in more than 2,000 responses to our consultation, which generally suggest that there are issues of irresponsible access?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
Are we now getting it right? Does it look as though that balance is now changing? We have gone from five years of trying to reinforce the code, through 10 years of saying, “Fill your boots—come into our countryside, because it’s good for your health and it’s accessible and you’ve got the right to roam,” to saying, “Oh, my goodness—we’ve been through Covid, and now we need to do something about this because there’s an issue.” Are we moving in the right direction?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
My apologies—it was at the previous committee meeting that someone suggested that the legislation should be more black and white. I think that you have an alternative position.
You mentioned case law. Do we need more case law, to clear up the grey areas, rather than being prescriptive with legislation?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
Goodness—where do I start? You guys are probably the elite when it comes to dealing with public access in national parks and wherever else. It is somewhat disappointing that we will not hear oral evidence from Dumfries and Galloway, a region that has been named as one of the top destinations in the world—it is the only place in the United Kingdom that was mentioned in National Geographic’s list of places to visit in 2027. I hope that we will get the chance to hear from them, because you guys set the standard—there is no doubt about that. However, that may well be because you are well resourced, and we know that other areas are not as well resourced.
Colin Simpson, you touched on the issues of health and mental wellbeing. In a previous committee meeting, we heard that encouraging more people into the countryside saves money for the health service—I think that it saves £500 million. It is about getting the balance right. We have also heard about ring-fenced funding for rangers—Kenny Auld touched on that.
What is the one thing that prevents the Scottish outdoor access code from performing as well as it might? Is it a lack of resources or a lack of education? What one change would make the greatest difference in achieving better responsible access?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
I put this question specifically to Kenny Auld. For ranger services, what is the one change that would make the biggest difference? Education is about potential control. Is that the best way? Should we be putting more funding into ranger services?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
I will broaden this out. My position is that, given that we are in the middle of a discussion on public service reform, any discussion around the future of the Scottish Land Commission should form part of that, rather than it being for us to take a piecemeal approach by reviewing one commission.
Whether or not you recognise this as a problem, cabinet secretary, I do not believe that the concentration of land ownership has been addressed. Has the commission delivered what it was set up to deliver? The key question is whether its functions are best delivered through a stand-alone organisation or should be absorbed into existing Government structures and agencies as part of public sector reform. The functions that are currently undertaken by the commission need to be considered within the wider piece of public service reform. They should not be seen as just part of a piecemeal decision that we are taking today.
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
I have real concerns, particularly on the back of Ariane Burgess’s contribution. I believe that land reform ultimately involves political choices, which should be made by ministers. I have concerns about mission creep with the Land Commission, which has, in my view, increasingly sought to influence the choices that should be on the table, rather than simply providing evidence on which those choices should be based.
09:45
I have a lot of sympathy with Donald MacKinnon’s argument that the decision is rather piecemeal and that it should form part of a bigger piece of work looking at public sector reform. I believe that the function of the Scottish Land Commission should be, and could well be, better delivered through being absorbed into existing structures such as NatureScot, Forestry and Land Scotland, and local authorities. That is not just about cost savings; it is about streamlining the public sector to avoid duplication, ensuring that policy, advice, research and stakeholder engagement are delivered as effectively as possible. This is not the time or the place to make that change, but, given that we do not believe that the Scottish Land Commission is the best way to deliver value for money or the best service, I am not minded to support Donald MacKinnon’s motion to annul.
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
Mark Johnston, ultimately, your sector had to respond to what some would suggest was a focus that was too much away from responsible access and too much on just access. That came at about the same time that ring-fenced funding for ranger services across Scotland was cut. Do you have the same view as Peter Rawcliffe—that the balance was right—or were there additional pressures on the ability of the decreasing number of rangers across Scotland to police those extra people, who did not have, historically or culturally, the same view on how to access responsibly?
Rural Affairs Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Finlay Carson
Peter Rawcliffe, exactly how much does NatureScot spend on promoting the code at the moment? My understanding is that it is less than £100,000 a year. Is that right? What are we looking at, currently, for promoting the code?