The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 15 contributions
Health, Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Maree Todd
I recognise that point, and we spoke about that a great deal when I met the lived experience advisory panel yesterday. I hope that I was able to reassure it that all its work has not gone to waste. We have absorbed the lived experience and now better understand how it feels to try to navigate the system and where we need to work harder to deliver better. Individual experiences are very useful in that respect. As a Government, we have also learned a great deal about how to use lived experience from population groups that are often considered heard to reach and to make sure that that experience is heard and acted on in Government. Therefore, none of the work that people have done to help us understand their situation has been wasted.
I was able to point to some tangible differences that have been made with regard to policy reform, service improvement and targeted investment. For example, there is the coming home work for individuals with learning disabilities. It is a devastating situation; so many individuals have been cared for far from home in institutions, and it has taken some time to build a system that is now delivering an impact. We are making a difference: we now have a dynamic support register, which means that we know who those people are and where they are in the system. That gives us good visibility at both the national and local levels.
11:00
We now have the targeted investment into the independent living fund that was announced earlier this year. I am absolutely confident that that will bear fruit and support people to come home from institutions and live in their communities. Ms Thewliss leads on that work, which is undoubtedly having an impact. I see signs of progress where we have been able to take that approach.
People’s human rights are at the core of that work, including the rights to be supported to live a healthy and fulfilling life and to maintain a family life. I am absolutely delighted and am confident that we can make progress. It is not a case of those needs being deprioritised; rather, we are just approaching them in a different way. Legislation is hard to implement and takes a long time to bear fruit. We saw that in England with the Down Syndrome Act 2022, which was passed a number of years ago but has yet to be implemented and is not yet making a difference. The urgency is so acute that we must make a difference right now, and I am determined to do that.
Health, Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Maree Todd
We have that divide, because physical activity and sport are not the same. Although they go hand in hand, they are not the same, and the word “sport” puts a lot of people off. I cannot understand why myself, but that is the reality.
We have a strong physical activity strategy, which is in line with the World Health Organization’s work. We have been working on it for many years, with solid success, aided by a phenomenal academic sector that has helped us to make sure that everyone in Scotland has more opportunities to move more often.
You are right about Edinburgh Leisure. I have been to one of its falls classes, and it was absolutely phenomenal. It was led by an absolutely outstanding, incredibly talented physical instructor—I think that his name was Michael McIntyre, but I might have got that wrong—who has the power to get people moving, even when they are really quite incapacitated, and to give them confidence to continue living in their own homes, even when they have had difficult experiences.
I spoke to some of the individuals at that class. One elderly gentleman, who was very tall, had fallen into the bath and his wife could not get him out. There had been trauma associated with getting him help and support, but there they were at that class, working out how they would cope if they got into that situation again, what they would need to have close at hand so that they could call for help, and how not to panic but instead to move on to their front and get safely back up on to their feet. The class was full of simple but clever stuff, and it was delivered in a way that absolutely boosted people’s confidence. A lot of the class was about giving people confidence, after traumatic experiences, so that they could continue living independently and be confident that support would be provided if they needed it. It was great.
Health, Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Maree Todd
There is no evidence to support that hypothesis. What we see is that people who are very vulnerable and are using in the street—which is highly risky; they are likely to die taking drugs—are able to take drugs in a safe environment. They are able to access not just naloxone to reverse overdoses, but advice on safe injection technique. It is a sterile environment. A lot of harm, including amputations as well as deaths, is occurring because of injection site reactions and infections. There is also public health harm that comes from sharing needles and using drugs in unsanitary conditions. The Thistle is intended to reduce the risks associated with all those harms.
In the Thistle’s first year and a half, up to the end of August, it has registered more than 800 people. It has overseen more than 15,000 injecting episodes, and I would wager that that is 15,000 injections that could have happened outdoors, in the street. That is 15,000 needles not on the street, because the needles are safely disposed of after use. It has responded to 195 medical emergencies. Those will range from probably requiring just a bit of support with breathing and monitoring to full-blown resuscitation. We have absolutely no doubt that the facility has prevented deaths. In a country that is experiencing such a high level of drug-related deaths, that is absolutely something that we should continue to explore, study and scrutinise, and we should make decisions about whether it might be useful elsewhere.
A facility like the Thistle is being explored for Edinburgh. The effort on that has been led largely from the ground up. There are many people in the community who, because of the level of harm that they are seeing, are keen to explore a safe drug consumption room. I think that the consultation on that has now concluded. We will work with the City of Edinburgh Council to find out what we can do to bring that facility into being, should the council and the citizens of Edinburgh decide that that should be done. That is not a straightforward process, because the UK’s Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 prevents us from having safe drug consumption rooms. We have to work with the Lord Advocate very carefully to ensure that we meet the legal needs—the laws of the land need to literally be lifted in a particular geographical area in order for that harm reduction to proceed.
Health, Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Maree Todd
A number of strategies are under way. Core training is available to those on undergraduate courses, and there is access to continuing professional development for regulated professions, which helps them to support individuals with neurodivergence.
I visited Windygoul primary school last week—I think it might be in your constituency.
Health, Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 16 September 2026
Maree Todd
I was probably being a bit too broad in my statement about lifting the law of the land, but it helps people to understand that it is not a straightforward case of Edinburgh just being able to do what Glasgow did. The Thistle project involved a careful process of working with the Lord Advocate and the community to assure ourselves about the limited circumstances in which we can change how prosecution policy applies in a specific geographical area.
The top of my list of ways to fully take a harm reduction approach would be to devolve drug laws, because the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 prevents us from taking such an approach. Examples of the challenges that exist are the creation of safe consumption rooms and the provision of tourniquets, because the law prevents us from providing sterile tourniquets and paraphernalia, which is the category that tourniquets come under. The Thistle has an exceptionally sterile environment, but people need to, for example, tie shoelaces around their arms to pop their veins up so that they can inject. Even a layperson can see the risks that are associated with that; if a person were to go into a hospital environment to get an injection, they would expect a sterile tourniquet to be used.
The law also prevents us from providing inhalation pipes. One of the greatest harms that we face in Scotland at the moment is the injection of cocaine. One reason that that is so harmful is that people take cocaine in bursts and, as the day progresses, they become intoxicated and their injection technique becomes poorer, so they face more harm in relation to the injection site. Cocaine is also a local anaesthetic, so people do not feel pain if they get it wrong. Therefore, encouraging people to smoke cocaine rather than inject it, and providing them with the tools to do so safely, would be a reasonable harm reduction strategy, but we are prevented from doing that.
There are strong reasons why we want to take a different approach, overarching all of which is the devastating level of drug deaths in Scotland. I sometimes wonder whether my colleagues in England quite appreciate the level of harm that we are facing—we are having different conversations in Scotland than those that are happening in England. If my colleagues in England do not want to take the approaches that we do, the most straightforward way to solve that problem would be to devolve the power to us so that we can take those harm reduction approaches.
11:30