The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I know that you heard from the SFC about the negative reconciliation, and I will quote some of its forecasting here today, because that is a normal approach to Scotland’s public finances. The SFC has published a couple of blogs, which I am sure the committee will be familiar with and which look at the variation in reconciliation across the piece. That is a common feature of our approach to Scotland’s finances.
More broadly, the £720 million reconciliation is a normal part of the fiscal framework. I made the point in my opening statement that the opportunity to reform the fiscal framework is coming up through the review, and I would welcome the committee’s views on how we can strengthen that opportunity, which is not without challenge.
We have seen stronger than expected growth in UK income tax receipts and have tools to mitigate that. As you mentioned, convener, we can borrow, but we have exceeded our borrowing limit. We also have an opportunity through income tax and our approach to that tax is more progressive in Scotland, so we are able to offset some of that. The forecasting from the SFC shows that £1.2 billion more has been raised in this financial year than in 2025-26, so our approach to taxation gives us opportunities to mitigate that.
On your broader point, that shows the fragility of Scotland’s finances because of volatility that we cannot always plan for. If you look at the SFC’s blog, you will see the variation in forecasting errors from 2019 right up to last financial year. It is challenging for the Government to manage that variation, so I think that the long-term solution will come from the opportunity that is presented by the review of the fiscal framework.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I have not said that.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
However, I expect that a further devolution agenda will come with that additionality. The interesting thing about the Prime Minister, of course, is that he has been clear that his approach to engaging with the Scottish Government will be not to override the Scottish Parliament. We welcome that, and that is exactly why the debate yesterday was in a cross-party space. It was an open debate on local government reform to give us an opportunity to have that shared approach to how we drive the reform that we need in our communities.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
However, with regard to your overall point, Mr Brown, if you look at the evidence from the SFC—I made this point to the convener—you will see that there is volatility in the forecasting. There is movement and fluctuation, and there are errors in budget forecasting, whether it be from the SFC or the OBR. That makes it really challenging for us in Government, because of the uncertainty. A broader point around the fiscal framework review is how we ultimately resolve that. Given the uncertainty in-year, we do not want to be having to plug gaps that we could not account for because some of the forecasting was perhaps not where it should have been.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
That is right. I was just reflecting with my officials that I think that local government in Scotland has greater borrowing powers than the Scottish Government, which is, when you think about it, not really how it should be.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
The fiscal framework is fundamentally flawed and is weighted to the south-east and to London, to the detriment not just of Scotland but of regions within England and of the devolved Governments across these islands. Figures for regions in England show us the economic challenge that is created by that. There are opportunities in the fiscal framework review to strengthen the approach that is being provided for at the current time, to equalise the situation and to recognise the different strengths that exist in all economies across the United Kingdom. We will all want to move forward on those opportunities.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I am taking advice on that. We will have to review the pay policy. Colleagues will be aware that we set limits for three years and we are coming to the end of that cycle. Decision making about the pay policy will be informed by the settlement from the UKG, so we will need to be mindful of that. My expectation is that we will approach that policy in a different way going forward.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
The real risk on capital just now is defence spend. We have built in some of our own calculations on defence spend, which my officials might have to hand. We have forecast some of the capital increases that we think will flow from increased defence spend, and that will not be without challenge. Of course, the proof will be in the pudding when it comes to the UK Government budget: we will find out in the coming weeks where we are on capital, but the defence spend is driving some of the challenge here, because it has come from departmental cuts, and that has a consequential impact on our budget in Scotland.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I accept the first point: they are off course at the current time. It would be remiss of me not to say that, because the data tells us that.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Everybody is playing their part—and it is fair to say what you have said. The issue around some of the growth that we have seen is in the national health service, and that is challenging, for a variety of different reasons. As the committee knows, about half the Government’s budget is devoted to the national health service. The growth that we have seen is in the national health service, across a range of health boards, and that is important for context—but it is not without challenge.
The fiscal sustainability delivery plan, to which you referred, was ambitious. It had a focus on reducing by 0.5 per cent per annum, on average, to 2029-30—taking us to a cumulative reduction of 2.5 per cent. I do not think that that cumulative reduction will be felt evenly across the public sector. That is fair to say because, for example, we need to invest in our national health service, as we all accept. We want to protect front-line workers. I had big debates with local authorities about teacher numbers in the previous session. We want to protect certain elements of our public sector, because we recognise that that is important.
The scale of the challenge is beyond doubt, and it would be remiss of me not to accept the challenge that Mr McArthur puts on those—