The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I would probably disagree with your point about outcomes. We have increased the number of young people going on to positive destinations. You will need to correct me if I am wrong, because it is a few months now since I worked on the education brief, but I think that the attainment gap narrowed by two thirds between 2008-9 and last year. That gap is narrowing and far more young people are now going on to positive destinations than was ever the case in 2008-9. I think that outcome is evidence of progress, because many of those young people would previously have left school with nothing to go on to. If we look at the positive destination data, we see that about 97 per cent of school leavers are going on to employment, training or work. That outcome is really important and is to be celebrated.
There will always be young people who are unable to do that, because of a variety of different individual circumstances. Their head teachers, parents and carers will know more about that than we do, but it is important to say that the trajectory of outcomes has actually been improving for almost 20 years.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
It is not a case of what I say: those are official statistics that I would be more than happy to share with the committee.
When you ask about challenges with the economy, are you talking about the working age population?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
To clarify, Mr Kerr, do you mean, to counter the rise that there has been in the past year?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
The data to which we have access is out of date, so I did not feel that giving an update to Parliament at this time would be helpful, given that the UK Government’s budget is in four weeks’ time. We would be giving a medium-term update in advance of a UK Government budget, with a brand-new Prime Minister and chancellor—who, incidentally, have already taken decisions on defence spending which we think will have negative impacts for us in-year. That is relevant.
I took the view that that would not be the most appropriate and prudent approach, because we would be giving Parliament an update that was informed by data that would, three or four weeks later, be out of date and by data from March that is also out of date, because it predates the Iran invasion.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I invite Jennie Barugh to come in on the specifics.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I do not think that the Government’s approach has changed—we will probably disagree on that, Mr Kerr. We have to look again at the political shifts that have happened in fairly short order. Forgive me—which year was it that you cited? Was it 2017?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
The commitment just now is annually, as I think we rehearsed with Mr Kerr.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Since 2017, we have had a variety of Prime Ministers and chancellors, who have all taken different financial decisions—that includes Liz Truss and the mini-budget in 2022. There has been quite a lot of volatility in terms of political shifts.
It is prudent for me to remind the committee that a decision was taken in advance of the elections not to set out a medium-term financial strategy. On coming into post, I reflected on the position at that time, and it was my intention to bring forward a statement. We then had a change of Prime Minister—I wrote to the committee on these points—and a change of chancellor.
The approach that the new UK Government is taking on the issues is markedly different from that of its predecessors. I welcome some of the movement on further devolution for Scotland and the additional finance that I would expect would flow from that. However, there has been a shift in the political make-up, and it is prudent for the Government of the day to reflect on that and not necessarily to be bound because of the circumstances that Mr Kerr has relayed. Circumstances change, and Government has to respond accordingly.
To go back to the original point about the OBR, Mr Kerr seems to be asking me to use outdated data from the OBR to provide an update to Parliament that I know would be inaccurate. I do not think that that would be helpful to Parliament with regard to the scrutiny and transparency that members expect. I think that you should have the most up-to-date data possible, which is exactly why we decided not to make a statement at that point. I hope that, in the coming weeks, the transparency that the UK Government will provide us with will help to inform the Parliament’s understanding.
More broadly, with regard to some of the information for which Mr Kerr is asking me, I should say that I also seek that information from my counterpart in the UK Government. Two weeks ago, I met the Chief Secretary to the Treasury and made those points about information sharing. It would certainly help the Scottish Government in our approach to long-term forecasting if there was better sharing of information and data from the UK Government to inform our decision making. I would then, with regard to my approach to the committee, be able to share that data with you more readily.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
You are right that a broad range of savings were identified through the portfolio efficiency and reform plans. I think that it was £2.6 billion from reform, including workforce savings and reprioritisation. That is across Government, and that takes us right up to 2029-30.
With regard to an update on that, I am happy to write to the committee on the detail. I will defer to officials on this, but I do not think that we committed to publish information line by line by portfolio. However, that was, and is, being driven forward. It was discussed—although I cannot go into it—yesterday at Cabinet, and it is regularly monitored across the Government.
In my previous role in education, we were held to account on our portfolio efficiency and reform plans—all cabinet secretaries are engaged in that process. I refer the committee back to the publication in January that set out every portfolio’s savings targets and the quantum that every cabinet secretary was expected to deliver. That is currently being monitored internally, but I would be happy to write to the committee with further detail on it.
There is an opportunity through the budget to reset some of the work on the transparency angle, and I would welcome the committee’s views on how you might want data to be shared in that regard. We need to learn from this approach—the approach that we took last year, as I understand it, was the first-ever time that we, as a Government, had published the long-term savings picture across the piece, and that locked in cabinet secretaries to those savings. It is important that we learn from that experience and provide that additional data to the committee throughout the year, where we can do so. We monitor the issue internally, but I am happy to reflect, with officials, on how we can communicate that to the committee as the year progresses, particularly in advance of the budget.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Good morning. I am pleased to appear before the committee for the first time as part of your pre-budget scrutiny for 2027-28. I am sure that I will be back on a number of occasions in the coming months.
I welcome the committee’s continuing scrutiny of the budget process and the insights that it has helped to provide, as well as the wider engagement with stakeholders that it brings. I have been following your evidence sessions and I know that members have explored a range of issues, which I am sure we will go into today, relating to the affordability and sustainability of Scotland’s tax and spending plans.
It is fair to say that the recent evidence from Professor Graeme Roy from the Scottish Fiscal Commission set out the scale of the challenge that we face. He highlighted the weaker economic outlook and higher inflation than was previously forecast. That reflects rising energy prices—on which we have again seen reports today—that are driven by the developments in the middle east, which are feeding through to the wider global economy and harming our constituents. At the same time, demand for public services continues to grow.
These are not simply figures on a page. They have real consequences for households all over Scotland. The recently published “Scottish Economic Insights” report highlights a widening gap in consumer sentiments between higher and lower socioeconomic groups, underlining how unevenly the pressures are being felt.
Professor Roy also emphasised that the current fiscal framework gives the Scottish Government relatively limited tools to manage volatility. That reinforces the importance of the forthcoming fiscal framework review, and I will welcome the committee’s views as we take forward that work.
The challenges that we face are real. However, as we navigate them, it is important to keep sight of the strengths that underpin Scotland’s economy and public finances. That was reflected this week when Standard & Poor’s reaffirmed Scotland’s high investment grade credit rating, providing independent recognition of our approach to fiscal management and our commitment to sustainable public finances.
Considerable uncertainty also remains around the outcome of the United Kingdom Government’s budget. During tomorrow’s debate, I will set out this Government’s priorities and where we need to see action from the UK Government. I am calling on the Chancellor of the Exchequer to deliver a budget that will support families on the cost of living and enable us to continue to invest in the services and infrastructure on which our people rely.
Despite that challenging backdrop, the Government is clear about its mission to ensure that public services remain affordable, sustainable and focused on delivering the greatest impact for the people of Scotland. That means maintaining a clear focus on reform, improving productivity, delivering efficiencies and ensuring that resources are directed to the Government’s highest priorities.
Many of those themes have featured in the committee’s inquiry. The fiscal pressures that we face are long term and structural, and meeting them will require an open and informed debate and good cross-party collaboration across Parliament about our priorities, trade-offs and the choices that lie ahead. Last week, I brought together members from across the Parliament for a round-table discussion on the economic and fiscal outlook to help to build a shared understanding of the challenges that we face as we approach the budget. I will do that again following publication of the UK Government’s budget on 28 October, and I extend an invitation to all members of the committee to attend that update.
Although there will not always be agreement on every decision, I believe that there is significant common ground on our shared ambition to protect vital public services and improve outcomes for the people who we all serve. I welcome the committee’s contribution to that debate, and I look forward to hearing members’ questions and views.