The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
On that latter point, it would be difficult to evidence that, if it has been the case.
More broadly, you will be aware of the Government’s position on the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020. Our view was that it was not required—alignment was provided for through the common frameworks, so there was no need to legislate in that space. We have a new Prime Minister coming in who wants to refocus the UK’s relationship with the European Union, so there might be an opportunity through that agenda to look again at the role of the 2020 act and whether it is required. The Scottish Government’s view is that it is not.
On clarification and UK Government engagement, in my experience, that varies bill by bill. With certain pieces of legislation, we might require extensive levels of interaction—one of the bills that is referred to in the correspondence to the committee might require extensive engagement, although we do not yet know and we cannot prejudge the outcome of the consultative process.
For example, with the Education (Scotland) Bill in the previous session, which I led on and which sought to replace the Scottish Qualifications Authority, we had a lot of engagement with the UK Government on legislation in that space that predated devolution. We had to engage with the UK Government on a section 104 order to allow the UK Government to legislate to dissolve the SQA so that we could then create Qualifications Scotland.
Sometimes, such engagement happens routinely in relation to legislation, for good reason, and we can work collaboratively—the Education (Scotland) Bill is a good example of that. However, there have been other occasions, which the committee will be well aware of, in which such engagement has not happened. The interaction varies according to the legislation.
I might bring in Chris Mackie on overall monitoring. Officials regularly monitor the way in which legislation that is proposed by the Scottish Government interacts with reserved competences to ensure that we do not have disagreement and that we can pass laws that affect the people of Scotland to best effect. I will bring in Chris on the overall monitoring from an official perspective.