Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 16 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 211 contributions

|

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

The member is absolutely correct to say that the First Minister leads on constitutional matters. I lead on intergovernmental relations. Mr Gethins was before the committee last week to discuss his responsibilities, particularly those relating to the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020 and his wider work on our engagement with the European Union.

More broadly, there is a shared approach. The First Minister leads on the constitution and, of course, the committee is entitled to call any minister it wishes to take evidence from in that regard. I am more than happy to answer in relation to my own responsibilities today.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

That is a great question, Mr Brown. It is a difficult issue. We are not going to agree on independence with the UK Government—that is plain to see. It is important to reflect that, although we need to try to engage on intergovernmental relations, that does not detract from our belief in independence for Scotland and our belief that the people of Scotland should have the right to choose in a democratic independence referendum.

Mr Burnham’s commentary on this issue in recent weeks, months and years has been interesting. In the past, he talked about the constitutional question not being settled. He said:

“In terms of a referendum, I’m not going to say, ‘No, not ever.’”

There are some words that he has used in the past—not in his current role—that suggested that he was amenable to a referendum taking place. Since taking up office as Prime Minister, he has, of course, resisted that idea. We do not think that that position is sustainable, nor do we think that that is the position of the people of Scotland. Ultimately, this is not about support for independence per se; it is about the people’s right to choose. Therefore, we will continue to pursue the matter with the Prime Minister.

To respond to your overall point, Mr Brown, we recognise that there is a disconnect between having a Prime Minister who, on the one hand, is in favour of further devolution but who, on the other hand, says, “But not that type of devolution.” This should ultimately be a matter for the people to decide on.

However, we need to try to work with the UK Government for the best interests of our people. I am committed to delivering that in an intergovernmental space, but that does not detract from the overarching constitutional question. The elephant is still in the room—we have not addressed it. Therefore, we will continue to pursue that point with the UK Government and other interested parties. Of course, Wales and Northern Ireland are now led by independence-supporting ministers, and that constitutional shift across the United Kingdom means that this issue will not go away and cannot be resisted.

I understand the UK Government’s positioning on the matter. It has also made its view on Northern Ireland very clear, which, in a constitutional space, has come with some other challenges with regard to what it might mean for people who live in Northern Ireland.

Andy Burnham saying no does not mean that independence is off the table—far from it. Actually, it irritates most folk in Scotland when they hear people say that a referendum is not going to happen. Regardless of whether they believe in independence, most people in Scotland believe that they should have the right to decide on their country’s constitutional future.

Your question speaks to the heart of the issue, which is that there is a Prime Minister who is pursuing a devolution agenda that is at odds with our overall view as a Government that Scotland should one day regain our independence. You have hit on an important point, Mr Brown, and it is challenging. We must still have conversations in an intergovernmental space, but that does not detract from our pursuit of independence for the people of Scotland.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

As I understand it.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

Yes.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

You have raised a really interesting point. We have, through the intergovernmental review, a pretty well-established architecture, but you are absolutely correct to say that the level of engagement often depends on individuals.

My own experience is that, under the previous Prime Minister, we had a shift in tone and an approach to resetting the relationship—I think that the previous committee covered that over the past two years—but then probably not a lot changed. Warm words are not necessarily action. We are now 50 days into Andy Burnham’s time as Prime Minister, and we now need to see some follow-up action. That will be the proof of better intergovernmental meetings—or, indeed, engagement. To my mind, this is not just about the meetings that happen but about the follow-up action that takes place as a result of that engagement and the change that takes place accordingly.

There is a well-established approach to interministerial engagement, but I would observe that, at ministerial level, and certainly in my experience as cab sec, such engagement can be ad hoc, more sporadic and dependent on a variety of factors, not least diary availability. In my role, particularly the finance element of it, there is much more of a regular drumbeat of engagement at interministerial level. That is probably for good reason and perhaps something that is understood, but I think that that approach differs from that taken by other parts of Government.

As for Mr Brown’s other point about ad hoc meetings when the Prime Minister comes to Scotland, one might ask whether that could be planned for in the future. Absolutely, and the committee might want to reflect on how we might have that sort of transparency and that regular drumbeat of meetings taking place at certain set points in the year. Indeed, that has been, in general terms, the approach taken by the British-Irish Council.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

No, it is not an approach that we have considered. It is not an approach that we have ever taken in Scotland.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I attended the interministerial standing council in June in Belfast and met a number of ministers at that time. I think that it must have been a matter of days after Keir Starmer resigned, and no one from the UK Government was able to attend that meeting. Three secretaries of state joined online, and we had in person the Northern Ireland First Minister and Deputy First Minister, myself from the Scottish Government and, I think, the finance minister from the Welsh Government—

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

That is a good question. Politics is at play on some of these issues, and we should be pragmatic about that. For example, the UNCRC bill was supported on a cross-party basis and there were no contentious issues about it, but the UK Government decided to challenge it and, ultimately, we had to relegislate in a much more narrowly defined way. That was challenging, because we had engaged with the UK Government throughout that process, during the session from 2016 to 2021. There was also cross-party support for the GRR legislation and engagement throughout the process. However, at the end of the process, after the bill had been passed, the UK Government decided to act.

Therefore, politics is sometimes at play during negotiations, and that is not good for the passage of legislation in this Parliament. It is also not great for MSPs, who spend inordinate amounts of their time in committees such as this one or in the chamber debating amendments and putting forward their views. To have legislation thwarted at the 11th hour feels deeply undemocratic at times, and the Parliament should reflect on that. There are better ways for all Parliaments to legislate.

The approach that previous UK Governments have taken in that regard has not, ultimately, been helpful. However, the number of breaches of the Sewel convention has reduced under the current Labour Government. I do not think that we have had any thus far, which is certainly welcome, so there has been a shift in that regard.

We have lots of examples of late legislative consent memorandums coming up, and, as you will all remember, in the last week of term before the summer recess, we had a number of late LCMs. That means that things are rushed through, with the Parliament not having adequate time to interrogate the details. We will continue to work with the UK Government on such issues. Part of the issue was the timing of the King’s speech. There are better ways in which we can work with the UK Government so that we get advance sight and advance warning of legislation. That would be in the best interests of MSPs and the UK Government.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I will be candid in saying that I am fairly sure we have not yet had any engagement with the UK Government regarding the development of the MOU.

You are right to say that that was committed to in 2024. We had little or no engagement with the UK Government on that until last summer, when there was some limited engagement, but the new Prime Minister’s team have, thus far, not engaged at all on the issue. We expect that that will come, but I am unable to share any further detail in that regard because we have not had any further detail from the incoming Prime Minister and his team.

Chris may want to say more about that.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

There are a number of issues to unpack in that. In my correspondence with the committee—it was issued only yesterday, so apologies in advance if colleagues have not yet seen it—I set out a number of areas in which we think that there will be interaction relating to key pieces of legislation, such as the food prices bill, the football banning orders bill and the budget bill. More broadly, I draw members’ attention to the final paragraph, in which I state:

“At this stage, no firm conclusions have been reached”,

given the engagement that will have to take place across a number of areas of legislation. However, we will continue to assess those opportunities. At this stage, it is quite early in the day to identify the level of engagement that will be required on the bills, not least because some are at the consultative stage, so it would be difficult for me to specify that.

On engagement on the programme for government more broadly, I am happy to engage with the committee as bills develop. I think that relevant ministers will respond to the committee on what falls within their responsibilities.

On the broader issue of transparency, which I know the committee’s predecessor pursued in the previous session of Parliament, I have looked at that committee’s report on the written agreement and transparency. In a number of areas, the Government has agreed with some of the recommendations. As I understand it, work will restart in the autumn involving the Scottish Parliament clerks and Scottish Government officials to update the written agreement and respond specifically to the predecessor committee’s recommendations, and particularly in relation to engagement on the programme for government, which was the point that you raised, convener. I know that the committee has a specific interest in that area, which is reflected in some of the correspondence that we have shared in recent days.