The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I recognise that there is currently an element of debate around the policy. I am mindful that a wider event is happening today that is being convened by ministers. I think that the NFU is attending the event along with a number of other stakeholders, which will be helpful. I hear some of the challenge in relation to the policy, but it is also the case that folk are struggling at the moment. This is a policy that the Scottish National Party put in our manifesto and it is one that we want to implement in government, because we recognise that the cost of living crisis that is ongoing across the country is really challenging for our constituents and we want to take action. That is what the policy is about. However, we are in the consultative period, so I do not want to prejudge the outcome of that consultation.
The policy is accounted for in the correspondence to the committee as an area that we might have to work on with the UK Government in relation to UKIMA and how that might apply, and whether an exclusion could be applied. However, again, I do not want to prejudge the outcome of that process.
I go back to some of the points that I made about the new Prime Minister—if he is still in the new phase; I think that he probably is. He was very clear in his meeting with the First Minister that he will not seek to override the Scottish Parliament and foist something on us; he wants to work with us. Therefore, I suppose that this is a test of his intent in relation to the wider issue of the use of the internal market act and how it has been used previously.
There is an opportunity for Mr Burnham, with his new approach, to recognise the Scottish Parliament’s locus in those issues. Again, I do not want to prejudge the outcome of the consultation and, certainly, we do not want to have a constitutional debate about this. Ultimately, it is about making life easier for our constituents who are struggling with high costs, whether that is in relation to food or energy prices.
09:45
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Absolutely.
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Yes, very much so. I am keen to work with the UK Government on all those matters. As the programme for government sets out, there is an opportunity for public service reform with local government and we are considering what further powers might mean. The Government is keen to work with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and our wider trade union partners, as well as the public, so that we can listen to their views about current local government services. I am sure that all MSPs will have views from their constituents about the provision of local services in their communities. It is important that we get things right for folk and that, where things are not working, we use public service reform as an opportunity to drive an approach that better meets people’s needs. There is an opportunity to learn from each other and to recognise that the needs of local communities are distinct. We want to continue that work with the UK Government and have already made representations in a number of areas around further devolution.
As I say, it is early days, and we want to work with the Prime Minister. A wider top-tier meeting with the PM and the leaders of the devolved Governments will take place in October. We will write to the committee with further detail on that. I expect that those issues will be pursued in that forum. The Prime Minister met the mayors of England fairly early on during his tenure. He did that quite distinctly and separately from the devolved Governments, which differs from the approach that was taken by his predecessor. It is a welcome shift and perhaps provides recognition that the needs of the devolved Governments, as the Governments of nations, differ from those of mayors in other parts of the United Kingdom. Nonetheless, there is learning that we can take from that process. We will continue to work with the UK Government in good faith on those issues, but the devil will be in the detail.
It is early days, so I do not want to prejudge the outcome of the negotiations. The Prime Minister is very pro-devolution and, of course, as a Government, we are in favour of devolution. We will continue to work with the UK Government on powers flowing back to Scotland. There will also be wider constitutional questions, which we may or may not come onto today. I will not talk to those in specific detail just now.
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I am happy to do so. There are a number of meetings coming up. I will be chairing the interministerial standing committee in the autumn, to which I think I alluded earlier—and we are still confirming a date for that. I will be attending the finance interministerial standing committee in Cardiff on 18 September, which is next week. We expect the interministerial groups to resume their engagement throughout the autumn. There are already a planned series of engagements that the committee should be aware of. I am more than happy to write with further detail on any of those matters to provide the committee with the transparency that you have asked for.
The written agreement and the overall review are being taken forward between Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government officials. As I understand it, that is restarting in the autumn, and I am sure that the committee will take a keen interest in the outcome of that wider review of the written agreement.
Do you have a last-minute bid for a supplementary question, Keith?
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Absolutely.
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Behaviour, yes.
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
That has not been addressed specifically at any of my interministerial meetings thus far, either at the BIC or at the interministerial meeting in Belfast. However, I would be more than happy to raise it when we next meet.
I think that there has been a lot of work more broadly in that area over a number of years. The intergovernmental review took some time to carry out, the committee interrogated it and we have looked again at structures. In the Scottish Government, there is absolutely a willingness to strengthen the structures that already exist and to have greater transparency. However, you are absolutely right to say we need that four-nations approach, and we need other parts of the UK to buy into that as well. I do not want to speak on behalf of other legislatures in that respect, but certainly there is a willingness from the Scottish Government to have that joint working. I will raise that issue at the next opportunity in an interministerial space to seek the views of others. I would be more than happy to correspond with the committee on that point.
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
To be candid with the committee, we do not yet have detail on the proposals from the UK Government, so it would be challenging for me to provide an assessment of that. We have a different arrangement in Scotland—for example, we do not have mayors, as is well understood by colleagues, nor would we necessarily want to go down that route. However, as I said in my response to Mr Green, there is an opportunity here to use this to strengthen local democracy, so we will continue to work with the UK Government in that regard.
As I mentioned, I was in the meeting between the Prime Minister and the First Minister. The Prime Minister was very keen to look at the agenda in terms of what it would mean for Scotland. He also seemed to recognise that further devolution of powers to Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales would look different from what exists in England, and even that recognition is different from that which came before. We will work with the Prime Minister and his new team in good faith on all these issues, because I think that that will lead to the best outcome for the people we represent.
However, we do not yet have detail on what any proposals will mean for Scotland, so we will have to judge that on its merits as and when those proposals are put forward. I would expect that we will see more ahead of the top-tier meeting that is scheduled for the coming weeks between the PM, the FM and the leaders of the other devolved Governments. We would certainly expect that further detail will be shared by UK Government officials ahead of that meeting.
I will just clarify with Chris Mackie that we do not at this stage have any proposals from the UK Government.
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Yes, I think that there is an opportunity to develop such an approach, and part of that opportunity might be to strengthen Sewel through the proposed memorandum of understanding, which I note was part of Labour’s manifesto. We think that restoring confidence in Sewel is really important in that regard, and there is perhaps an opportunity through the MOU to explore the structures further.
However, it is really challenging. You set out a range of examples, and we have heard from Ms Young about other examples of legislation with which there have been challenges. The actions of the previous Conservative Government undermined Sewel, but there is an opportunity through the MOU to look again at the issue. That will require engagement between the Scottish and UK Governments, if it is to work adequately for both of us.
Your reflections on the Smith commission are certainly interesting, in terms of a framework, because we do not currently have a framework in that space that would meet—
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 8 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Thank you, convener. Good morning. I welcome the opportunity to discuss the Scottish Government’s priorities for intergovernmental relations. As you might recall, my first Government role was as the Minister for Europe and International Development, working to Michael Russell, the Cabinet Secretary for the Constitution, Europe and External Affairs. When I was reading the committee’s public paper yesterday, I had to reflect that, although some things have changed since 2020, some things feel remarkably similar.
Nonetheless, six years and five Prime Ministers later, the United Kingdom’s political landscape looks markedly different. Particularly at the start of a new parliamentary session, there is an opportunity to be grasped to reset how our respective Governments can work together in the interests of the people we all represent. In that spirit, I welcome the UK Government’s commitment to a more collaborative and constructive approach to intergovernmental relations. Ultimately, though, good intentions must be matched by demonstrable progress.
The Scottish Government will continue to engage constructively, based on mutual respect, with a focus on practical outcomes. Those principles are not new. They are reflected in the arrangements that were established through the intergovernmental relations review in 2022, and my priority is to ensure that they deliver effectively in practice.
I have already seen at first hand the value of effective intergovernmental engagement through forums such as the interministerial standing committee and the British-Irish Council. Discussions in those forums provide important opportunities to address shared challenges, exchange perspectives and identify practical solutions. That experience has also reinforced the importance of engaging in good faith and working closely with the UK Government, the Welsh Government and the Northern Ireland Executive. As Deputy First Minister, I will continue to press for the Scottish Government to be involved in early discussions that affect devolved responsibilities and the people of Scotland.
Effective scrutiny also has an important role to play in supporting transparency, accountability and public confidence. I look forward to continuing constructive dialogue with the committee in that regard, and I look forward to questions from committee members.