Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 16 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 211 contributions

|

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I thought that Mr Kerr might ask me a number of questions on that issue. I have been responding to his PQs, and I am sympathetic to some of the points that he has made.

It is fair to say that the instruments apply to the Highlands and Islands and focus on issues there. There are specific connectivity issues that are unique to the Highlands and Islands and that do not apply to the north-east. The Highlands and Islands account for 51 per cent of Scotland’s land mass but less than 9 per cent of Scotland’s population. Five of the six local authorities in the Highlands and Islands have the lowest population densities. There are broader connectivity issues that, arguably, do not apply to the north-east of Scotland, although Mr Kerr might have a different view on that.

Research from 2018 that looked at journey times showed that people in towns and communities across the Highlands faced journey times of two to three hours just to reach Inverness. I do not think that we have data to suggest that journey times have changed since that analysis was carried out.

More broadly, the approach that we have taken to the setting of rates will keep us in line with the UK Government for the next year, but, as we approach the budget, such matters will need to be considered in the round. If Mr Kerr feels strongly about the issue, I will engage with him during the budget process. I am sympathetic to some of the points that he has made, but the Scottish statutory instruments that are before the committee are focused on the Highlands and Islands.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

As I understand it, the 2018 data does not sit in a silo. We used more up-to-date passenger data to inform the regulations. Mr Kerr makes a valid point about Covid and changes to travel patterns. We did not use only the data from 2018. I think that the 2018 data relates to journey times. We have taken account of more up-to-date information about passenger numbers and travel routes.

I will bring in Martin Davidson to talk about the specifics of the dates.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I followed some of the evidence that the committee took last week from John Sturrock, and an interesting point was raised, which might have been from Mr Marra or Mr Kerr. It was about whether legislative change can lead to cultural change. In itself, I do not think that it can. It reminded me of debates that we had over the Education (Scotland) Bill in the previous parliamentary session, because legislating to replace an exam board does not in itself change culture; it is about how the legislation is interpreted and how it is enacted by public bodies.

Some provisions of the Public Office (Accountability) Bill relate to training, as I understand it. The Hillsborough Law Now campaign, which I mentioned, has proposed a training programme for public officials. Kate Forbes was involved in that work in the previous parliamentary session, and we would be supportive of that coming forward to help to inform wider cultural change.

My other observation on cultural change is that the chronology of the introduction of the bill is quite interesting, in that it interacts with public service reform, to some extent. If we want to drive a public service reform agenda, there is a need for cultural change. Some of these principles will flow into the wider work that is being led by Mr McKee, but it will take time, because, ultimately, it is about changing behaviours and improving the culture within our public services. Through public service reform and the training that I alluded to in relation to the work of the Hillsborough Law Now campaign, there are opportunities to drive some of that work forward.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

They absolutely should be. The FOI legislation is a great example. I do not know how many FOIs the Scottish Government is currently dealing with, but it is a huge number, and a huge amount of officials’ time is devoted to responding to those requests. One of the points that was made last week was about public inquiries not becoming an industry, perhaps in a similar way.

I also heard John Sturrock’s evidence about the move from defensiveness and denial to candour. That will not happen overnight as a result of the legislation; it will take time. However, if we are able to deliver on the proactive duty to share information and to come forward and share details, it will help our approach to public inquiries. John Sturrock made the point that, when people are engaged in public inquiries, they are looking for an acceptance of responsibility. However, that discussion can sometimes take far too long and cost far too much public money. The Finance and Public Administration Committee in session 6 wrote a significant report on that, which I am sure we will come on to talk about.

There are opportunities here for people who have been victims to get access to justice far more timeously than they otherwise might have. The behaviour change that you talked about will take time to develop, and the automatic defensiveness and protectionism that exist will take time to break down. The legislation will be part of that, but we will need to work on the wider training. You are right to mention the public service reform agenda, which allows us a unique opportunity to drive forward the behaviour change that we need to see.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I do not think that we do, because the data is very difficult to collect. As Martin Davidson has rightly set out, we would need further powers from the UK Government to take further action, and it would be quite challenging to even gather the evidence and the data that would be required. We will engage with the UK Government on those issues, and I should say that the UK Government has engaged very positively with us in relation to ADT and the block grant adjustment that will be required, as was set out in the letter that I shared with the committee.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

The private jet tax is not a standalone tax; it is a special rate of ADT that is applicable only to private jets, and it will be provided via secondary legislation. I will set out the ADT rates for 2028-29 during the budget process, when I will say a little bit more on that.

I am not able to say anything further in relation to the ghost flights, but officials may want to add something. We are taking policy advice on that issue. It is quite challenging to establish data on some of these matters, given their complexity. There is also an issue around devolved and reserved powers. I will defer to officials on the wider ghost flights issue.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

We engaged with the Competition and Markets Authority on its work on voluntary referrals. It had an issue relating to capacity at the time, so I am not sure that it was able to provide much assistance.

I will bring in officials on the wider point about comparable European Union countries and subsidy control.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I welcome Mr McArthur’s support for the proposals. He will appreciate that some of the work was undertaken prior to my time in office, so I will give him an outline of some of our engagement.

In the consultation, 85 per cent of respondents supported retaining the exemption for passengers travelling from airports in the Highlands and Islands to UK destinations, including—perhaps unsurprisingly—100 per cent of Highlands and Islands stakeholders. That data was important in informing our steps forward, as was the engagement that the previous cabinet secretary had with a range of stakeholders. I believe that Mr Flynn is meeting members on 28 October to have wider engagement on connectivity for the communities that they represent. I should mention, too, the ADT expert advisory group, which includes a range of representatives. It was convened in March and has met on a number of occasions.

All of that engagement has helped to feed into the broader policy, but I might defer to officials on the issue of how the ask of communities informed our approach to shaping policy.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I think that it is both things. It is a policy choice that we as the Government have made, but, thinking back to my period as transport minister in 2022, I know that this has been a long-running issue for many years, and we have not been able to resolve it. Brexit was part of the challenge, and the engagement with the UK Government has been helpful in that regard. You will see from my letter to the committee that we have had very strong engagement with the Chief Secretary to the Treasury on this matter and the UK Government has agreed to the approach that has been set out.

I do not know whether Martin wants to say anything more about the subsidy control rules element, but I would say that we have been able to work very proactively with the UK Government in quite a short period of time since I came into office to get this over the line and take the next steps.

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I think that Mr Kerr is pursuing the point about the difference in the treatment of Aberdeen and Inverness airports. The reason for that goes back to the data on journey times and the isolation that Highlands and Islands communities experience. We would argue that the connectivity argument does not apply in the same way to the north-east. I think that that is the point that Mr Kerr is making—he is shaking his head, so I am happy to hear more.