The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
The Accounts Commission has been clear that, I think, local government finance has increased in real terms in every one of the previous four financial years and, of course, last year was a record settlement of £15.7 billion, so I do not accept all of the challenge there. However, undoubtedly, the fiscal outlook for Scotland is challenging, and perhaps we will come on to talk about that later. We will also have to reflect on the spending review and on how it is informed by decisions that the UK Government takes in terms of where Scotland can go in that regard.
We have always done our best to protect and enhance the local government settlement. We have done that in the previous four financial years, and I will continue to work with local government partners on how we can best protect their spending and look at opportunities for enhancements, where we are able to deliver those. I must reflect that we are in very challenging financial times and that all parts of government will be impacted by that. As we approach the budget, we will discuss those issues in more detail with the committee.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
If I could reflect on my time as cabinet secretary during the budget process, we were very keen, through the portfolio efficiency plans that all cabinet secretaries set out to Parliament in January, to protect front-line workers. That was a key aspiration and focus for all cabinet secretaries.
However, I have to reflect that, at the current time, as the First Minister has said, our view is that the size of the public sector in Scotland must reduce. That will bring with it a level of head count reduction.
Our focus, though, is very much on protecting front-line workers, I do not want to prejudge the outcome of where we get to with local government and trade unions in that regard, but I give an assurance that our focus is on protecting front-line workers.
It will not surprise the committee to hear that, in my previous ministerial role in education, I was very keen throughout the past few years to protect teacher numbers. That was a really important input, because having the right number of staff in our schools, when we talk about, for example, the PISA results, is hugely important.
Mindful of the impact of reducing front-line head count, we, as a Government, have been very focused on protecting that so far. That has been our approach as set out in the portfolio efficiency savings plans that were communicated to Parliament earlier this year.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I did hear him.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I heard Councillor Bell expressing his views. I certainly wish Councillor Aitken well. She has led Glasgow City Council extremely well over a number of years. I welcome Councillor Bell to his post and will meet him officially after he is appointed.
You heard the views of the First Minister and of the Government regarding local connection during First Minister’s questions last week. We do not take the view that that policy is a challenge, but we are of the view that UK Government asylum policy has created real challenges for local authorities. The root cause in Glasgow is a broken asylum policy and we have repeatedly asked the UK Government to look again at that policy, to treat people with dignity and respect and to reconsider its approach. We support Glasgow City Council’s call for the UK Government to provide adequate funding for newly recognised refugees and communities and we have communicated our view to the UK Government.
In fairness, as I said in my opening comments, we have seen a shift in direction, so I am hopeful that the UK Government will listen to the asks from the Scottish Government and from Glasgow City Council. We do not share the view that you have expressed regarding the local connection rule. We want to treat people with dignity and respect. Our view on funding is that the issue relates to the UK Government’s approach to asylum, which is why we will pursue the issue of that financial challenge with that Government.
09:45
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I have had my initial meeting with the chancellor and I have also corresponded with the UK Government about some of those issues, as has the Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice. We have not received a response to either of the letters, but we have specifically raised the issues. I am happy to share copies of the correspondence with the committee, if that is helpful, and to share a response from the UK Government, as and when we receive it.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Come to Fife.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I thank Ms MacCallum for her question. That has never been put to me before. I am more than happy to take advice from officials and write to the committee on that.
The wider challenge of re-entering the jobs market and having served in elected office, particularly if someone has been a local councillor, must be very challenging. I will take that away as a suggestion from today's committee, if Ms MacCallum would be content, and I will be happy to correspond with the committee on the art of the possible on that topic. She raised a very important and interesting point.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
That is an interesting point. I am conscious that there was a case in Glasgow recently, and I do not want to stray into providing public commentary on that, for obvious reasons.
The relationship that councillors have with their officers is very different, I think, from the relationship that ministers have with officials who provide us with advice—with which we can agree or which we can ask to change. I regularly speak to my officials and, although we will have different approaches to the advice, we will always have a conversation and a discursive space around it.
Although my experience probably does not match what you have set out, I hear the challenge. However, it is difficult for me to provide public commentary on the matter. When I was education secretary, I was often quite surprised to read in the press commentary from officials in Glasgow City Council, for example, and in other parts of the country. I would say to my Scottish Government officials that it was interesting because you would never read public commentary from a civil servant in the same space. The way in which official advice is given to councillors differs from the way in which it is given to ministers, so I would reflect on that difference.
However, you alight on a challenge. Although it is difficult for me to provide commentary on it, I think that there might be an opportunity to consider some of those issues in the round through PSR. I would wish COSLA, rather than the Scottish Government, to lead on the issue, given that it has the expertise. I would be keen to hear what COSLA’s holistic view on the matter might be; the Government could then respond to that accordingly through the three-month period of engagement.
I should say that COSLA has not highlighted the matter with me thus far in the engagement process, but I am keen to hear all views in relation to public service reform, including how our councillors are supported to carry out their democratic duties. That is actually the nub of your question, convener—how our councillors can deliver in the communities that they are elected to represent.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Ms Campbell hits on an important point in relation to budgets and transparency. The tension that exists between our local authorities and NHS providers in our communities is often to the detriment of our constituents. We have created structures that are not necessarily delivering in the ways that they were originally intended, which is why PSR is really necessary.
Prevention is a key theme that runs through the programme for government. Public service reform is not just about saving money, which, of course, we must deliver in relation to the public purse, but about building a preventative approach into our services. By changing our approach to budgets and improving alignment between health and local government, we will have a much more consistent and strategic approach to the issues that the member has raised today. Those aspects are often quite challenging for councillors at local level to defend or explain to their constituents because of the tensions that exist between different budget lines.
PSR is an opportunity to look at how we can reform that process to ensure that we are driving a prevention agenda, which is often pulled in different directions. It will allow us to build prevention into our budgeting processes at a much earlier stage, to the benefit of our constituents.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Mr Bouse hits on a really important point. A lot of work that is undertaken at local level is really good. As MSPs, we all see that in our communities. They might not be things that get shared in the chamber, but fantastic work is happening in our local communities that, often, is driven at council level and not at Scottish Government level. We should recognise that and not lose it in the mire of public service reform.
I had not appreciated how many councillors we have around this committee—there are a number of you.
There are opportunities to share best practice through strategic approaches. Looking at how we share services definitely has to be one of the ways in which we deliver public service efficiency and save money, which we know needs to happen as a result of this process; another way is by sharing good practice. The Ayrshires were given as an example of that earlier.
Still in the PSR space, I will lean on work not in local government but that the NHS is leading on. Last Wednesday morning, I was in Kirkcaldy to see their hospital-at-home approach and chatted to some of the clinicians there about their challenges in sharing medical information between clinicians across health boards. We know that that impacts on patient care; as a result, things are slowed down, and patients do not necessarily receive the type of care that they could have if we had a more efficient approach. That situation exists in local government, all over the place. In education, we have lots of systems across our local authorities—why do we duplicate things? There are real opportunities for savings and for a more efficient approach that will ultimately be better for our communities.
The test of public service reform will be the public’s view of their local services. To my mind, this is not just about engagement with trade unions and COSLA; it also has to be about engagement with the public. Prior to the evidence session, we discussed with officials how to build that into the three-month period. The committee might have strong views on that or might be able to assist in hearing views from the public.
As I say, ultimately, the test of public service reform is if things get better for folk in their local communities, and everyone knows when things are working well. There are opportunities to share services and deliver that strategic approach across the country. Through PSR, there are also opportunities to listen to the folk who we all represent. That should not just be a one-off event that happens during an election. It should be a key part of the way in which we, as elected members, reflect on how we are carrying out our duties. The real test of public service reform will relate to public engagement.