The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
We think that our capital funding might reduce by £370 million in total over the four-year period, taking us to 2029-30. Those are estimates just now. We will of course find out on the day of the UK Government budget, but that is what we are planning for. It will be challenging.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Again, the council tax approach that we have taken has been reliant on cross-party support. When it comes to the levying of council tax, I do not think that there will be movement, but I do not want to prejudge the outcome of a consultation. We are in a consultative period with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Indeed.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Yes—the bonds offer us an opportunity to borrow in a different way. I go back to the point that I made to Ms Stafford about attracting inward investment. The bonds allow us to do that and to market Scotland in a way that traditional borrowing might not.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I know.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Yes—the portfolios are many and varied.
With regard to how we quantify preventative spend, there are challenges with that. I would always argue that all education spend is preventative, but others might take a different view. We are developing a tool that will help with the tagging process, and that will help to inform the wider cross-Government approach.
It is challenging, because there are different portfolio budget lines across Government. In this budget, a number of portfolios will come together for the first time, which is interesting. We have a slimmed-down Cabinet and we have budget lines that have moved together for the first time, so I see an opportunity for us to better understand the preventative story between and across portfolios as a result of different areas merging.
A great example is the merging of culture and education. There is a music line in the budget—I think that it is for the youth music initiative, which comes from the culture budget but is delivered in an educational context. That is preventative spend, if we quantify it in a way that measures output. To go back to the point that Kim Schmulian made, the academic evidence suggests that, if you experience music at school, you are much more likely to go on and be resilient in life, and there are broader economic benefits to be gleaned from that.
How we tag and measure that is much more challenging, and the tool is our answer to that. I accept that it is tricky, particularly given the variety of portfolio areas, but we are doing our best to do that through the new budget approach, and we will set out some of that in the coming weeks. We are undertaking that work on a cross-portfolio basis just now.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Yes—if there is greater spending. I know from my experience as a cabinet secretary and as a minister that ministers always keep a watchful eye on decisions that are taken by the UK Government. If we think about it from a prudent financial strategy perspective, that is not great for taking a long-term approach if reactive changes happen in-year. I accept your general point about consequentials and what we can do with those things.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I set this out in response to the opening question from the convener. What we would quantify as the gap was identified in the MTFS. It was £2.6 billion by 2029-30, and a capital gap of £2.1 billion by 2029-30. That is the gap only if we take no action—PSR is very relevant in that regard.
We know what is driving some of the challenge: demographic challenges, inflationary impacts and constrained public sector growth. We need to take action on those points: £2.6 billion will be delivered through public service reform, which includes workforce reform and the reprioritisation that I spoke about in response to Mr McArthur, as well as our approaches to economic growth and to taxation.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
We recognise it, but, as you will be aware, the UK has one of the highest borrowing rates in comparison with other mainland European countries. We have extremely high borrowing rates, which the chancellor himself has spoken about, so there are opportunities to reform the way in which the UK Government borrows in order to lessen that cost. That is not a matter for me, but we would support the calls that the chancellor has set out, because we want to drive forward economic growth. There are opportunities for reform in that regard.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 30 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I have seen the evidence sessions that you have had on these topics, and I think that the issue has been rehearsed in the chamber as well. If we were to raise the higher-rate threshold to the level that it is in England, that would cost us more than £800 million in this financial year alone. However, we recognise the importance of the marginal tax rates in the design of the tax system. The Fraser of Allander Institute has published evidence on the idea of looking at the issue in a revenue-neutral way, which would ultimately require us to make significant increases to the basic and intermediate rates. This is not a niche issue that can be identified just on its own.
Ultimately, our broader position as a Government is that the full powers of income tax and national insurance contributions should be devolved to Scotland, so that we can take decisions in a more holistic way, which would allow us to ameliorate some of the challenges that Mr Kerr speaks to.
More generally, on the behavioural change point, having tested this with officials earlier on, I can say that some of the behavioural change aspects of the issue are difficult to quantify. It is difficult to measure things such as people choosing to change their behaviour by, for example, going down to four days a week. We have undertaken some work with His Majesty's Revenue and Customs on this, and I would be more than happy to share that with you. However, there is an issue around data lag, which Lucy O’Carroll may want to pick up.