The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Just to close off that point, the DPLR Committee’s concern was about the role of the Scottish ministers in the matter. I was content that the Scottish ministers’ consent would be sought in relation to the provisions in clause 16. We will write to the committee with further detail on that, but the DPLR Committee has been keen to seek further detail on that principled approach. I want to be as candid as I am able to be at this time. However, given that we are still in dialogue with the UK Government on a range of those matters, I will be more than happy to facilitate writing to the committee when we have clarified those points further with the UK Government.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Absolutely. Obviously, the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport has a key role to play, and later this month he will convene a meeting with a number of MSPs on those issues. In itself, that shows the Government's willingness to lead on those matters.
I know how important those flights are for the communities that Mr McArthur represents, but also for the broader Highlands and Islands region. Those are lifeline flights, as Mr McArthur set out earlier, so it is hugely important that the Government plays a role. We already play a significant role in relation to our PSO flights, but, with the introduction of the new tax, there will be a greater opportunity for us to support those island communities in rural parts of Scotland. We will continue to show that leadership, and Mr McArthur has an assurance from the Government in that regard.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
It is fair to say that we will maintain an approach to direct engagement on the issue of routes and connectivity. We have an interest in relation to our public service obligation routes in particular, so we will continue to monitor the situation with regard to passenger uptake. We will also monitor the development of the policy and how it interacts with passenger behaviour.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
One of the points that I mentioned in my opening statement was that we had uploaded to the UK Government's subsidy transparency database details of the exemption on 17 July. That sat for a month, when any interested party could raise a concern about legal challenge. As no interested party did so, our view is that there is no obvious opportunity for legal challenge, given that the opportunity to raise such a challenge has now expired. We have been through that process, and we are as assured as we can be that no challenge will be presented.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I know that that is Mr Kerr’s view, and I would be more than happy to meet him to discuss the matter. As the committee will understand, I cannot share the detail of legal advice that I have received in my capacity as a minister. Our view is that there would not be a distortion of the kind that Mr Kerr has outlined. However, I am happy to engage with him on the issue, because I understand the points that he has made about the communities that he represents. While the instruments before the committee are focused on the Highlands and Islands, I recognise that there are connectivity issues in the north-east of Scotland as well.
10:45
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I have written to the DPLR Committee, and it is fair to say that, as I set out in my introductory remarks, we are in close contact with the UK Government on those matters. It remains our principled position that the Scottish ministers should be responsible for Scottish and devolved matters. However, given that we are taking a four-nations approach, we are engaged with the UK Government on a range of different matters. I will be more than happy to write to the committee when it is clear how the secretary of state’s guidance-making power is proposed to operate within a devolved context. However, we are clear that Scottish ministers’ consent would be fundamental to the guidance.
There was a separate matter on the regulation-making powers in clause 16. That clause defines who holds public office for the purposes of the two new statutory offences of misconduct in public office. Both the secretary of state and the Scottish ministers can take forward such regulations but, where the secretary of state takes forward such provisions, the bill makes it clear that it is subject to the Scottish ministers’ consent.
That safeguard protects the Scottish ministers’ role in relation to clause 16 but, on both those matters, we are still in dialogue with the UK Government, so I would be more than happy to share further detail with the committee as and when it is developed.
My officials might want to say more on the specific clauses.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Officials will correct me if I am wrong on this. As I understand it, there are issues with the intersection between the security services and the role of Police Scotland, but the bill will apply to Police Scotland. It will place responsibility on the head of a relevant public authority for ensuring compliance with obligations under the duty of candour and assistance. Police Scotland is operationally responsible for counter-terrorism policing, and it is independent of the Metropolitan Police. As I understand it, some elements of the provision are under discussion in relation to how they would interact across the UK, because of our differing approach to policing.
Officials are nodding at me, so it seems that I have said the correct thing.
09:45
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
As I have outlined to the convener, a lot of these issues relate to our on-going dialogue with the UK Government. However, I am content thus far that matters relating to clause 16 will be subject to the consent of the Scottish ministers. Building on that, I think it important to give the Parliament assurance that our powers in Scotland will not be overridden in any way.
It is worth while recounting the fact that Andy Burnham has made it clear that his approach to devolution will not seek to override this Parliament’s powers. That is a change from his predecessors’ view, and it is welcome. That in-built mechanism for protecting the Scottish ministers in relation to regulation-making powers and our consent gives us a degree of assurance, but, as I have said to the convener, those matters need to be discussed further with the UK Government.
I think that Francesca Morton wants to come in on the specifics of the office-holder point.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I will be candid and say that some of this predates my time in office. I do not know whether Jenny Brough wants to come in on that.
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2026
Jenny Gilruth
Good morning. Thank you for inviting me to support your scrutiny of the legislative consent for the Public Office (Accountability) Bill.
As you know, the bill encompasses the UK Government’s commitment to rebuilding public trust through ensuring that public officials perform their functions with candour and transparency at all times. The Scottish ministers are supportive of the principles of the bill. My predecessor Kate Forbes met the Hillsborough Law Now campaign earlier this year in relation to the legislation. I pay tribute to the campaigners’ enduring determination to secure changes in the aftermath of the Hillsborough disaster.
The Scottish Government has worked with the UK Government in support of Scotland’s interests relating to the legislation and reached an agreement on aspects of the bill that are within devolved competence.
The duty of candour and assistance will impose a duty on public authorities and public officials to act with candour, transparency and frankness in their dealings with inquiries and investigations, which includes proactive notification and the provision of information and assistance. That will aid in providing inquiries and investigations with factual and timely information as a standard obligation.
The bill also requires public authorities to promote, and take steps to maintain, high standards of ethical behaviour within their organisations. That will include the requirement to adopt and make publicly available a code of ethical conduct that sets out the standards of behaviour that will be expected of staff. The offence of misleading the public will seek to capture public authorities and public officials that intentionally mislead the public or are reckless as to whether their act will do so.
The bill also creates two statutory offences of misconduct in public office. The offences are informed by recommendations made by the Law Commission of England and Wales. They will replace the current common-law offence in England and Wales. Scotland does not have an existing offence of misconduct in public office, although a close comparator is the common-law offence of wilful neglect of duty by a public official. The Scottish ministers consider that there are strong benefits to extending those statutory offences to Scotland.
The bill will also amend the Legal Aid (Scotland) Act 1986, enabling the Scottish ministers to make regulations that modify that act in respect of the availability of non-means-tested legal aid to persons participating in fatal accident inquiries where a public authority is a participant. That will mirror the legal aid provisions for England and Wales and ensure that there is no disparity across the UK. That complements the commitment to Parliament made by the former Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs in early 2025 to introduce legislation that would provide non-means-tested legal aid for families participating in death-in-custody FAIs.
There has been, and continues to be, ongoing engagement with the UK, Welsh and Northern Irish Governments on a four-nations approach to the bill. The agreement that we have reached with the UK Government on amendments to the bill to ensure that the various provisions can operate effectively within the Scottish context has enabled us to recommend that the Parliament should now consent to the relevant provisions in the bill. In respect of further amendments that are relevant to devolved Scottish provisions, the Government is in close contact with the UK Government and will consider the need for any future LCMs as those amendments progress.
As I know the committee appreciates, the bill covers a broad range of portfolio matters. If questions touch on the portfolio lead responsibilities of my ministerial colleagues, I will ensure that the committee receives a follow-up response in writing with any additional information that would be of assistance in your scrutiny.
My officials and I are happy to take questions.