The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 162 contributions
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
Were the consultants who advised on the £100,000 cap the same as those who advised on the £100,000 cap?
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
You have mentioned already, and it is in your report, that the option fee cap was initially set at only £10,000. The rapid review increased it tenfold to £100,000 per square kilometre. Paragraph 23 of your report says:
“The final lease approach was agreed by the Crown Estate Scotland Board in January 2020”
and that
“This advice was accepted, and approved, by Scottish Government ministers.”
I think that you have already answered my question, but who recommended and advised the initial pricing strategy? Was it Aurora Energy?
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
The lack of transparency suggests that there is a plan that we are not seeing, or another way to look at it might be that there is no plan for how to spend the money.
A significant amount has been brought in through the ScotWind leasing. If that money continues to grow, we can understand why the Government would want to draw down that cash. However, as you said, it is not clear how things are going to pan out or whether or not the money is going to grow.
There needs to be some serious thinking about how the money is spent. Do we look at opportunities to boost the supply chain so that the whole thing takes off and we can grow more revenues in the longer term? Do we look at trying to increase demand for energy, for example, and the issues that David Kirkwood talked about earlier?
I suppose that my question is whether there is any serious thought about how best to spend the money. At the moment, we are just using it as a budget mechanism tool or a piggy bank for the Government to potentially raid if it needs to. Is there serious thought about how we are going to spend the money in the future so that the Scottish taxpayer gets value for money?
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
Thank you for your report. As you have acknowledged, the Scottish Government has committed £141 million across 17 projects, and there has been some progress. However, as you have also noted, the wider £500 million fund is making slow progress, and multiple risks threaten the potential to unlock billions of pounds of supply chain opportunities.
I was concerned to read that the Scottish Government does not have a clear plan from 2029 onwards. As you highlighted, I am also concerned about the limits to the potential to get public money back from offshore wind investment programmes and investments.
Clearly, the report is significantly linked to the ScotWind issue that we will discuss this morning. In the meeting on 29 October, I look forward to hearing from you on the report and the ability to get the most economic benefit from the investments that we make on behalf of the people of Scotland.
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
We move to agenda item 3, which is on the “Management of the ScotWind leasing round” report. I welcome our witnesses: Stephen Boyle, the Auditor General for Scotland; and, from Audit Scotland, Alison Cumming, executive director, performance audit and best value, and Martin McLauchlan, senior manager.
I invite the Auditor General to make a short opening statement.
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
The report covers what the Scottish Government is doing generally with the moneys from Scotland. Specifically, has Crown Estate Scotland or the Scottish Government given any indication on what the current financial penalties—if they are recovered at any point—will be used for? For example, will they be used to support jobs more generally or in the supply chain?
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2026
Neil Bibby
Thank you for your report and your opening statement. The Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Energy, Stephen Gethins, has claimed that the report vindicates the Scottish Government’s approach, but let us look at your audit. You explicitly refuse to give a value-for-money conclusion due to the high-risk nature of the project, and you have highlighted that no single business case was produced for the model. I am not asking you to judge policy decisions, but I would ask you to judge the accounting. How can the multibillion-pound strategy be vindicated when the public’s financial watchdog does not have the evidence that is required to prove that value for money has been achieved?
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 September 2026
Neil Bibby
Good morning. I welcome everyone to the fifth meeting in 2026 of the Public Audit Committee. Agenda item 1 is a decision on whether to take agenda items 4, 5, 6 and 7 in private. Do we agree to do so?
Members indicated agreement.
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 September 2026
Neil Bibby
Agenda item 2 is consideration of the report “The National Fraud Initiative in Scotland 2026”. I welcome our witnesses, who are all from Audit Scotland. They are: John Cornett, executive director of audit services; Martin McLauchlan, a senior manager; and Tim Bridle, an audit manager. I invite John Cornett to give an opening statement.
Public Audit Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 24 September 2026
Neil Bibby
Yes, but we are talking about two full-time jobs.