Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 8 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 31 contributions

|

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Fishing Industry

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Ariane Burgess

It has been great to have a fisheries debate, especially with the many new voices in the chamber. Let us maintain the debate as an annual fixture in the parliamentary calendar.

I will touch on a few of the amendments to the motion. I agree with Donald MacKinnon’s call for there to be thriving places, infrastructure, skills, and housing alongside the fishing industry. I share a growing concern about the cumulative impact on our marine area. We should be concerned that the amendment does not acknowledge the disparity in Scotland’s share of the fishing and coastal growth fund, but I am glad to hear that the member has taken up that concern with UK Government ministers.

It was good to hear James Adams speaking about compensation concerns, but I ask him where the backed-up sums are, so that we can see what that would cost.

I am supportive of Andrew Baxter’s concerns about the cumulative impact on our marine environment and I certainly share his calls for a review of the marine directorate’s capacity. Again, I note my concerns about the costs that would be involved with a compensatory framework, which I would like to understand.

In closing, I say that a healthy and resilient marine environment matters for so many reasons. Not only does it support our work towards achieving our 2045 carbon emissions reduction target; it safeguards a crucial public resource that can support jobs and prosperity in our coastal communities for generations to come. For too long, we have prioritised short-term gains over long-term sustainability, but the tide has started to turn.

I welcome the progress that the Government has made, but I want to go further and faster. I want every coastal community to thrive not just because they receive a fair share of the wealth that is generated from fishing but because they benefit from renewables developments, critical infrastructure and the wider opportunities that come from healthy, well-managed seas. The Government’s response to Environmental Standards Scotland’s report will be an important test of whether the ambition is matched by action over the course of the parliamentary session. The future of Scotland’s fishing industry depends on more than the fish that we catch today; it depends on the health of the seas that we leave behind and whether the communities who live beside them share fairly in their wealth.

17:12

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Fishing Industry

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Ariane Burgess

Will the minister take an intervention?

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Fishing Industry

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Ariane Burgess

I want to follow up on the point about the difference between HPMAs and the MPAs. The MPAs were carefully discussed in negotiations with the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation, which gave its full backing to what was proposed. I hope that the fishers that the member represents understand that the MPA proposals were negotiated in a very careful and thoughtful way over a long period of time, and that we need to move forward with them.

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Fishing Industry

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Ariane Burgess

I may speak for a little bit less than nine minutes, given that the minister accepted my intervention.

I thank the minister for securing the motion for debate. I hope that he will commit to making a fisheries debate an annual fixture in the parliamentary session instead of timing it around annual quota negotiations, as happened in the past. We need to be able to have a full and frank discussion about the range of issues that the sector faces and the challenges faced by our coastal communities, which rely on healthy seas to thrive.

Our coastal communities are at a crossroads. Decades of shortcomings in fisheries management and failures to adequately protect our marine environment, as well as a system that has not delivered for the people who rely on our seas, have contributed to the loss of jobs, concentrated wealth in fewer hands and accelerated depopulation. However, I welcome the minister’s awareness of the need to manage fish stocks more carefully. It is also heartening to see that community wealth building is high on the Government’s agenda.

Turning to the Government’s motion, I would hope that we all want a sustainable fishing industry that delivers for the economy and the environment, so that fishers and coastal communities of the future can continue to make a living and enjoy healthy lives by the sea. I share the Scottish Government’s ongoing frustration with the UK Government about the pitiful allocation that Scotland received from the fishing and coastal growth fund, which has already been debated somewhat this afternoon. That fund should support a more sustainable fishing industry and our coastal communities. However, it will not deliver nearly enough of that for Scotland because the share of the pot that we are receiving falls well below the relative size of Scotland’s contribution to the UK fishing sector.

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Fishing Industry

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Ariane Burgess

Although I would not use Keith Brown’s turn of phrase, I find it frustrating that Scotland is not sitting directly at the negotiating table when it comes to many of the issues to do with fishing.

The negotiations that are taking place this autumn will set catch limits for 2027, and mackerel shows what is at stake. For years, catches agreed by coastal states have exceeded scientific advice, putting the stock under considerable pressure. There are now encouraging signs, with scientific advice for 2027 suggesting that the stock is increasing, although it remains below the precautionary level. I am keen to hear whether the minister will press for catches to remain within the scientific advice and for all coastal states to agree a sharing arrangement that protects that recovery.

Where the Government’s motion falls short is in its lack of acknowledgement of some of the key issues affecting coastal communities. How we share out whatever is agreed matters just as much as the totals. The motion implies that the way in which quota is currently managed by the Government is good enough to deliver long-term prosperity to fishing communities. In fact, we have seen consolidation of a quota into fewer and fewer hands. Findings from Greenpeace show that 45 per cent of all Scottish fishing quotas are wholly or partly owned by just five wealthy families, yet the Fisheries Act 2020 requires fishing opportunities to be distributed using transparent and objective criteria, including environmental, social and economic factors. The act also requires ministers to seek to incentivise more selective fishing gear and techniques with a lower environmental impact.

I welcome, following my intervention, the minister’s consideration of a further consultation on the quota system and the potential for community quota initiatives. That would help us to move more rapidly towards the kind of quota system that the Fisheries Act 2020 requires of ministers. Quota is such an important tool in managing the health of our seas and the people who rely on them. A system that puts greater weight on social, economic and environmental benefit, and that incentivises fishing methods that are more in harmony with our marine environment, would do much to get us closer to that place.

That brings me to my amendment, because the Government’s motion also does not acknowledge the serious findings of the Environmental Standards Scotland report “Protecting Scotland’s seafloor: an assessment of Scottish Ministers’ implementation of the Marine Strategy Regulations 2010”, which came out in June. Scotland’s seafloor matters, because it underpins the marine ecosystem that our fish stocks rely on. Unlike most commercial fish, herring lay their eggs on the seabed. In Wester Ross, in my region, herring spawn has been found on maerl beds near Gairloch in 2018, 2019 and 2024. It is a powerful reminder that the health of fish populations begins with very local habitats. Maerl beds are also nurseries for young scallops and juvenile cod, and maerl grows so slowly that, once it is damaged by dredging or trawling, it is effectively lost. Our seabeds also store significant amounts of carbon, so we need the Government to maintain and protect that vital public resource. Environmental Standards Scotland has asked the Government to agree a remedial action plan within six months, and I would be interested to hear from the minister about when Parliament can expect to see that plan.

I could raise many more issues—spatial squeeze, landings, processing, the treatment of our international crews and the long-awaited consultation on inshore marine protected areas, for example—but I will use my closing minutes to look at what sits behind all of that, which is the question of how we plan and govern our seas. I remember being involved in the national conversation about the second national marine plan in June 2023, more than three years ago. The problems with marine planning go back much further than NMP2. Shetland and Orkney, which are both in my region, finally have regional marine plans in place, but, 16 years after the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010, they are still the only two of Scotland’s 11 marine regions to have such a plan. Does the Government intend all 11 marine regions to have regional marine plans? If so, when will the other nine regions follow, and how will those plans relate to NMP2?

Our regional inshore fisheries groups are advisory. By contrast, England has 10 statutory inshore fisheries and conservation authorities, which bring together local authorities, fishing interests, conservation expertise and local stakeholders with duties to manage inshore fisheries sustainably and powers to make and enforce local byelaws. Crucially, they manage fisheries and conservation together, which is exactly the connection that I have been making. I do not suggest that Scotland should simply copy that model, but we should ask whether our current system gives coastal communities and regional bodies enough responsibility, authority and resources to have a real say in how their marine environment is managed.

NMP2 gives us the opportunity not only to update national policy but to clarify the relationship between national and regional planning and to consider how stronger regional co-management could sit alongside that framework, with clear responsibilities, proper resources and genuine accountability for our seas. That is why my amendment calls for the national marine plan to be fully implemented.

I said at the start that our coastal communities are at a crossroads: one road carries on as we are, with a quota in fewer hands, a damaged seafloor and decisions that are made far from the people who live with them; the other road shares the benefits of our seas more fairly, protects the places where fish spawn and grow and gives coastal communities a real say over their waters. The Fisheries Act 2020 and the national marine plan give us the framework, and Environmental Standards Scotland has shown us where the Government is falling short. What is needed now is the will to follow through.

I move amendment S7M-01460.5, to insert at end:

“welcomes the findings of Environment Standards Scotland’s Protecting Scotland’s seafloor report, which calls on Scottish Ministers to take actions to meet their legal obligations to the marine environment, and believes that fully implementing the National Marine Plan is crucial to sustaining Scotland’s fishers and coastal communities for the long-term.”

16:13

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Fishing Industry

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Ariane Burgess

I am interested in what the minister is saying about the negotiations. Would he consider a further consultation on the quota system to potentially bring in community quota initiatives?

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Wildfires and Other Climate Shocks

Meeting date: 30 September 2026

Ariane Burgess

Scotland’s climate is changing, not in some distant future that we can plan for at our leisure but now, in extreme ways, with devastating and destructive impacts with which our smallest rural villages, our towns and, now, our cities are grappling and struggling.

We can take this summer as an example. I saw the impact of a rapidly changing climate during my visit to Nethy Bridge in the Cairngorms, where I saw exhausted people fighting to protect a proud community and the surrounding precious landscape from the flames of a vicious wildfire.

It is clear that relying on a short-term emergency response is no longer enough. Having seen the impact this summer, I emphasise that this debate is not about the good stuff that we are already doing with nature’s help—we all know about the targets to which we have committed on protecting Scotland’s nature by 2030. It is about the scale and the urgency with which we must respond to these intensifying events, putting prevention first.

Although land that is parched from weeks of hot weather and wildfire looks very different from high streets under floodwaters, those problems share a root cause. Decades of urbanisation, intensive farming and human-driven climate change have weakened Scotland’s natural defences to extreme weather. Nature can, and should, be our first line of defence, from peatlands, native woodlands and wetlands that act as natural sponges, soaking up excess water, to sand dunes that form natural flood barriers along coastlines. Healthy land soaks up rain, stores it and releases it slowly.

Sadly, in many communities, those habitats that act as natural buffers have been long neglected or stripped away. While nature is being seen as part of the solution, we must prioritise scaling up to increase our community’s resilience to extreme weather for the long term. A rapid landscape-scale approach is needed, and the Scottish Greens are calling for the Scottish and United Kingdom Governments to deliver a dedicated climate shock fund to cover the costs of preparing for, and preventing, damage from extreme weather. Our existing farming, environmental and flood support schemes fund vital work to tackle the climate and nature crisis, but dedicated funding is needed to ramp up work and remove barriers to implement the nature-based solutions that I mentioned earlier.

Scotland will get that work right only if we bring together groups such as emergency services, conservation and rewilding organisations, gamekeepers, estates, scientists, including ecologists, farmers, community groups and public sector organisations. The profound collective knowledge of those stakeholders is the most powerful tool that we have when it comes to making Scotland more resilient in the face of a changing climate. By sharing knowledge and best practice, we can prevent serious events and ensure that we are up to the challenge of insulating Scotland from climate shocks.

That is why we are also calling on the Scottish Government to demonstrate leadership and convene a landscape resilience summit on to enable a constructive, co-designed approach, such as that which we have seen with the Common Ground Forum on Sustainable Upland Deer Management. That would deliver solutions in the interests of building the most resilient landscape that we can.

Why is that so important? This summer, the Cairngorms were scorched by a wildfire that burned for almost a month; at its peak, Nethy Bridge and nearby campsites were evacuated. Urban areas have also been affected by wildfire, with Arthur’s Seat in central Edinburgh experiencing two major fires this summer. More than 230 severe wildfires were recorded by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service last year, and the fire at Dava moor in the Highlands was Scotland’s first recorded megafire—in four days, it burned almost as much land as Scotland loses to fires in a typical year. Analysis by the SFRS has suggested that, although wildfires in Scotland are almost always man made—some accidentally and some not—they almost all occur during dry weather.

Scotland is known around the world for its wet weather, but that, too, is changing. This year, several areas in eastern Scotland have experienced significant water scarcity, and 2025 was the driest year on record. Those conditions have been challenging for many sectors, including Scotland’s food producers, as crops have been impacted.

The parched landscape raises the risk of flooding. Today, 400,000 properties in Scotland—roughly one in eight homes and businesses—are at risk of flooding. Responding to flooding costs Scotland around £500 million per year, and that is expected to grow, with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency forecasting

“more frequent, more intense, and more damaging”

flooding in the years ahead. Flooding can have short-term and long-term impacts on people’s mental and physical health as they deal with the practical and financial consequences. The UK National Audit Office has estimated that

“for every £1 spent on protecting communities”

from flooding,

“around £9 in property damages and wider impacts”

can be avoided.

Turning to coastal areas, I note that it is predicted that the risk of flooding from the sea will more than double by the end of the century. In low-lying areas of my region, including South Uist, Orkney and Shetland, natural coastal barriers are giving way; homes are becoming uninsurable; land is losing value; and some communities face the prospect of having to move.

Human-made interventions have their place in some places. However, where they are used, they should work hand in hand with nature in order to keep costs down and support our progress towards climate and nature targets, and, most importantly, because there is no one-size-fits-all solution to improving landscape resilience. We know that nature-based solutions work across whole landscapes and they tackle several problems at once.

Scotland’s 2045 net zero target is among the most ambitious such targets in the world, and we must now see similar levels of ambition in action to increase our climate resilience. The UK Climate Change Committee tracked 33 climate-resilient outcomes for Scotland, but on 32 of them, we are failing to make sufficient progress. That is why I urge the Scottish Government to work with the UK Government to establish a dedicated climate shock fund, and to have ministers convene a Scottish landscape resilience summit. We can no longer stop climate change from impacting Scotland, but by partnering with nature, we can still make sure that we are ready and that no community is left to face it alone. The window to scale up our response is closing fast.

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Wildfires and Other Climate Shocks

Meeting date: 30 September 2026

Ariane Burgess

David Linden has talked about the Fire and Rescue Service needing to tackle wildfires, but does he agree that it is also the first line of support and rescue when it comes to flooding?

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

Wildfires and Other Climate Shocks

Meeting date: 30 September 2026

Ariane Burgess

I appreciate that the minister is choosing to focus on wildfires, but what I was trying to get at with my motion is not just wildfires but flooding, droughts, coastal erosion and soil erosion. As I said earlier, we have to acknowledge that the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service will also face flooding. The whole point of the debate is much broader than wildfires. That is the starting point, but we have to address all those issues. That is why I am calling for a climate shock fund and for the minister to bring forward a resilient landscape summit.

Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]

First Minister’s Question Time

Meeting date: 22 September 2026

Ariane Burgess

In the light of what scientists have said could be the biggest El Niño event for a thousand years—a climate event that is likely to lead to more extreme storms—the United Kingdom Government recently called for people to stock up on food and water. Given that the Highlands and Islands is usually on the front line of bad weather, I take that as a direct call to action for my constituents. Will the First Minister reassure people in my region that his Government has plans to support people in rural and island areas when extreme weather badly impacts the provision of food, water and other essential supplies?