The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 55 contributions
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
As is so often the case, Liam McArthur makes wise points, on which I am sure the minister will want to respond. The minister is committed to a meeting, and I look forward to hearing his summing-up speech.
I emphasise that, as well as retaining the human expertise, it is worth considering the research capability that goes alongside that. One of the pieces of work that I remember doing with engineers at Aquamarine Power, in the brief time that I worked there, looked at how this country—the UK—has historically had a comparative advantage in onshore wind technology. However, that advantage was lost, primarily to Denmark and Germany. Although the resource is potentially smaller, there is significant tidal and wave resource across the world, and we want Scottish technology companies to get the lion’s share of that market. We have a comparative advantage that, if we can, we should maintain.
18:00
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on its current utilisation of, and plans for, its Victoria Quay building and car parking facilities in Leith. (S7O-00497)
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
It is great to hear about more civil servants coming back to work in Leith. They always make such a positive impact when they are in the community, and they are obviously providing a public service. If the Scottish Government comes to the position that parts of the building are surplus to its requirements, there are so many opportunities, working with the people of Leith, to provide extra facilities from Victoria Quay for the benefit of the local area. For example, it could provide affordable creative work spaces and spaces for technology start-ups, including by, potentially, housing those currently in St Margaret’s house who are now being displaced. We also need a new police station in Leith, to allow police to move out of the old building they are currently using, and there is strong demand for more car parking facilities, especially to support local hospitality.
I would be really grateful if, together with relevant officials, the minister would commit to having a meeting in Leith to hear about those suggestions and how, if we work together, Victoria Quay can offer even more to the people of Leith.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
I, too, commend Donald MacKinnon for bringing the debate to the chamber.
The story of marine energy development in Scotland has been going on for several decades. As others have emphasised, it is important to distinguish between wave energy technology and tidal energy technology. They are part of the same grouping but are different in terms of their development and in the leadership and processes that have been involved in their journey thus far with regard to the innovation that has happened here, in our country.
Wave Energy Scotland’s creation, in 2014, followed quite significant public investment in a number of wave energy companies, including Pelamis, which Lorna Slater used to work for, and Aquamarine Power, which I used to work for. Those were two remarkable businesses that were trying to do ambitious things. However, as is the case with many innovative processes, they both got to a point where it was difficult to develop the technology in the commercial environment that they found themselves in. Wisely, to preserve the benefit of the expertise, investment, innovation and research that had accrued in the sector up to 2014, Wave Energy Scotland was created.
At the same time, there was the development of tidal technology, and many people transitioned from wave technology to tidal technology. In Scotland, we have, indeed, seen remarkable progress in the creation, deployment and, to an extent, commercialisation of tidal technology, including by Nova Innovation, which is headquartered in Leith, in my constituency, and deploys mostly in Liam McArthur’s constituency. I cite Nova Innovation in particular because it is a small company that has always engaged in remarkable and successful innovation. Its tidal technology development has been successful internationally, but it has often encountered challenges in gaining support for its technology in the UK. To an extent, that has involved the issue, which Alan Brown mentioned, of contracts for difference not having been forthcoming from UK Governments in past years, and it also partly involves what some have argued is an unfair emphasis on larger projects and deployments rather than on the success of our small and medium-sized enterprises that are involved in developing marine technology.
We have been on a journey. Mark Simpson emphasised his view of where there should be a prioritisation of public investment or commercial support for technological development. However, there would not be North Sea oil and gas drilling if there had not been investment, commercial or otherwise, in the innovation that is necessary to create the technology that that sector uses. If it were not for that investment, we would still be burning coal, to a large extent. Every energy transition has involved risk and investment.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
I would take an intervention, but I do not think that I have the capacity to do so.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
I will just say that that is one example. We used to assume that we could rely on good discipline in our classrooms. It is an example of the several things in our system—and in our society—that we cannot take for granted and on which we need to work together to make sure that they are improved.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
One of the things that I—and many others, I am sure—think about a lot at the moment is the breadth of the challenges that we face together as a democracy and a society. The fact that we face those together in a situation in which the pressure—[Interruption.] Sorry, Presiding Officer, there was just a mild distraction there. I will start again.
In a situation in which we face so much together as a society, and in which the constraints on us collectively are so large, the issue of educational improvement in a world that is changing so rapidly should be something that brings us together. What has been good in today’s debate—I commend the drafting of all the amendments and the leading proposition in the motion—is that this should be an issue that we can come together around and seek common solutions for our constituents.
Given the pressure in the current era, we as a Parliament need to get better at agreeing certain things collectively and working towards them in the medium and longer terms, instead of seeing short-term political opportunities. There can be almost no area that is more important than education. We come at this with a collective determination to help our young people, but we are in a world that is moving so rapidly in terms of technology and our economic competitiveness. Much of what we consider normal in our education system, as well as in others, will face challenge in the period ahead, in a way that we have not yet anticipated. We need to be cohesive in our adaptability to that.
Some of us—I mean those of us in the chamber and beyond—value the wisdom of people who have been in certain disciplines for a long time. We should respect their experience. However, we must also be cognisant and mindful that things are changing at pace and that our systems will need to flex and bend.
Further, we must hear from our young people. The younger generations in Scotland and elsewhere are remarkable. When I was at school at the turn of the century, there was a sense of optimism in the air. The world was getting better and things looked brighter. Our young people who are growing up now have gone through really challenging times and have had to build their resilience due to a massive financial crisis, huge changes in the constitutional set-up following Brexit, a pandemic, a war in Europe, continuing challenges from existential crises such as climate change, and the emerging challenge of artificial intelligence.
While we try to create greater excellence and equality in that situation, although the old necessities of numeracy and literacy are extremely important in our education system, aspects such as critical thinking, creativity, technological understanding and more vocational skills will become increasingly important.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
I say a big thank you to Daniel Johnson for bringing this important motion to the chamber. The trouble with being the last speaker in a debate is that most of the things that you were going to say have already been said, but I will make a couple of points.
As the constituency MSP for the Annandale Street headquarters, and now that my constituency borders the depot at King’s Road, as a representative, I feel deeply connected to this remarkable service that has been built up over four decades. It has not just kept Edinburgh moving but helped to drive its growing prosperity, as the fastest growing city in Scotland and an increasingly popular destination to come and live, work and visit. Much of that is because of the remarkable service that Lothian Buses delivers.
As a child of Edinburgh and as somebody who was around at the time that this amazing service was created, I have been using Lothian Buses since I was a bairn. I remember when the fare was in pence rather than pounds. Sometimes, trying to find the change in your pocket was a wee bit difficult, so I am glad that we have got past those points. I thank all the drivers who were gracious enough to let me off with a penny or two now and again over the years, as I went back and forth from football or whatever.
The service is amazing. Depending on where people live in the city, they almost do not need a car. Like many citizens of Edinburgh, I do not own a car. In many instances, people do not need a car when they have such a good bus service. However, we must not take the service for granted. I think about that a lot when I walk past the Annandale Street depot, as I do very often. When I see the drivers going back and forth, I often wonder which number of bus they are going to drive and where their day will take them.
The sheer number of remarkable people who are employed in all aspects of the service and what they have delivered for many years should absolutely be celebrated. That is particularly the case this year, and not just because of the anniversary. This summer, when there was a fire on Princes Street and the trams stopped running, as services were mobilising to try to deal with that as best they could, the one that stepped up and acted first was Lothian Buses. Let us remember that a festival happens in the city every summer, and that it is an event that is nearly as big as the world cup. Lothian Buses makes that happen in many ways. It is a key player every year and, particularly this year, its contribution was absolutely remarkable. We all owe Lothian Buses and every driver and other member of staff who helped in that situation for saving the day.
A lot has been said about how remarkable the municipal model is, how we must learn from it, and how it can be used as an inspiration and a way to adapt services elsewhere in the country. One thing that has not been mentioned is that Lothian Buses is accountable to the democracy, just as Scottish Water is. Just as private water companies are so unaccountable in England, some bus services elsewhere in Scotland are very unaccountable to the democracy. What is great about Lothian Buses is that it is a partner, and we can have discussions about increasing services, subsidising services and trying to fill gaps—it works together with elected representatives.
I am delighted with the exchange that I had with the cabinet secretary in recent days and that a visit is programmed for early in the new year. I know that Lothian Buses will be delighted to welcome the cabinet secretary to the Annandale Street depot and its headquarters to discuss more about what it has achieved, the challenges going forward and how its inspirational example and model can be used to help improve services for all of Scotland.
18:19
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
I will, if I have the capacity.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 November 2026
Ben Macpherson
I respect individuals and experts who argue strongly from their viewpoint of a need for more knowledge content in our education system. However, I also respect the position that adaptability, flexibility and the ethos of the curriculum for excellence were right for an emerging and changing world in the 21st century. Rather than the either/or situation that is sometimes presented, the truth is, as is so often the case—albeit not necessarily as much as it should be at the heart of our politics—in the middle, in the grey and the nuance. If we as a Parliament can get to that position on the issue of education, we, our debate and our society will be all the better for it.
The curriculum improvement cycle that is coming up presents an important opportunity, and I commend the Government for its leadership on that. We should all seek to feed into that constructively, as the profession and others have done. Constituents have brought me a number of points for feeding into that process, and I would be grateful if the Government would be open minded in hearing their positions. For example, one constituent, who is the youngest member of the biggest endometriosis support group in Scotland, seeks the placing of a greater focus on women’s health issues. I cite that as a small example—there are many others.
One area that others have, rightly, emphasised relates to some of the work of the Criminal Justice Committee. Although the cabinet secretary is absolutely right—and I could not agree more—that the vast majority of our young people are good and hard-working people who are achieving remarkable things, unfortunately, a minority of them are engaging in really challenging behaviour in our classrooms and streets. I fear that that minority is growing. We must work cohesively and collectively to address that issue before it continues to grow, because its consequences in our society, for those young people and those whom they affect, including teachers in our classrooms, are serious.