to Public Bodies in Scotland
Committee has written to the Cabinet Secretary for Finance about the
appointment of Willie Watt as Chair of the Scottish National Investment Bank.
work outside Parliament
Committee received some correspondence on 30 October 2019 from Gordon MacDonald
MSP about the Code of Conduct Rules which restrict MSPs’ ability to work as
lobbyists or parliamentary advisers. Mr MacDonald proposed that these could be
tightened up. The Committee responded to Gordon MacDonald’s letter on 2 March
2020. The Committee reviewed the Rules in this area, agreed that they were fit
for purpose but agreed to issue a reminder to all MSPs and to keep the matter
The Committee received some correspondence on 28 January 2020 from Gail Ross MSP about Remote Voting.
The Committee responded to Gail Ross on 27 February 2020.
The Committee received some correspondence on 5 February 2019 from David Stewart MSP about proxy voting.
The Committee responded to David Stewart’s letter on 5 March 2019. The Committee thought it would be helpful to await the outcome of a review of the pilot scheme in the House of Commons on proxy voting in order to determine what lessons could be learned about how proxy voting had worked in practice – and whether these might be applicable to the Scottish Parliament. The Committee therefore intends to return to the issue of proxy voting as part of its future work programme.
On 12 March 2020, the Committee agreed to ask MSPs for their views on whether proxy voting should be introduced in the Scottish Parliament.
Law Officers Answering Questions in the Chamber
The Committee has received correspondence from Mike Rumbles MSP and Adam Tomkins MSP about the Law Officers answering questions in the Chamber.
The Committee discussed this correspondence and agreed to write to the Scottish Government to ask for its views on the points it raised, and the proposal that Standing Orders should be amended. The Committee also agreed to seek information from the Scottish Government on how it is decided which oral questions are answered by the Law Officers and which by other Ministers.
Following receipt of the response from the Scottish Government, the
Committee discussed it at its meeting on 16
May and Mike Rumbles presented his case for revising Standing Orders. The
Committee then questioned the Minister for Parliamentary Business and Veterans
on the proposal at an evidence session on 30
Following the evidence session with the Minister, the Committee discussed
the issue and agreed that Standing Orders should not be changed and wrote to
Mike Rumbles MSP And Adam Tomkins MSP to inform them of its decision. A copy of
these letters is available below.
The letter from the Convener of the SPPA Committee to the Minister for
Parliamentary Business and Veterans includes a copy of the original
correspondence from Mike Rumbles MSP and Adam Tomkins MSP.
The Committee received a response from the Scottish Government on 20 March 2019.
Freedom of Information
At its meeting on 29 June the Committee considered the resolution of the Parliament agreed on 21 June 2017 on Scottish Government compliance with the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002, and noted the call for an independent inquiry and for post legislative scrutiny of the Act. The Committee agreed to write to the SPCB and, subsequently, the Scottish Government to seek their views on this matter.
Commission for Parliamentary Reform
At its meeting on 20 April 2017 the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee took evidence from the Commission on Parliamentary Reform. After that meeting the Chair of the Commission, John McCormick, wrote to the Committee with some additional information.
Scotland Act 2016
The Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee has been considering Standing Order rules changes in relation to the Scotland Act 2016 - super-majorities.
At its meeting on 2 March 2017 the Committee agreed to write to the Scottish Government for its views on the proposed Standing Order rule changes.
Parliamentary Liaison Officers
The Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee has been considering the issue of Parliamentary Liaison Officers.
At its meeting on 17 November 2016 the Committee agreed to write to the Scottish Government to recommend that the Ministerial Code be revised to extend the requirement on Parliamentary Liaison Officers to declare their status.