Skip to main content

Language: English / GĂ idhlig

Loading…

Chamber and committees

Question reference: S5W-15844

  • Asked by: Graham Simpson, MSP for Central Scotland, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
  • Date lodged: 9 April 2018
  • Current status: Answered by Kevin Stewart on 26 April 2018

Question

To ask the Scottish Government how many planning decisions in each local authority that went against a local development plan in which it was decided to (a) approve and (b) reject a plan were referred to it in (i) 2000, (ii) 2001, (iii) 2002, (iv) 2003, (v) 2004, (vi) 2005 and (vii) 2006, broken down by type of plan, and how many were overturned following referral.


Answer

We do not hold the requested information centrally. Certain applications which were considered to be a significant departure were notified to Ministers as described below.

Prior to 2007 the notification categories were quite extensive and there were around 20 different triggers for notification. These covered applications such as development: on agricultural land; affecting trunk roads; affecting nature conservation; likely to result in loss of outdoor sports facilities; affecting a scheduled monument or category A listed building; involving wind generators etc as well as contrary to approved structure and local plans.

Category 8 Development contrary to approved structure and local plans

(a) Any development which the planning authority considers to be a significant departure from a structure plan approved by the Secretary of State under section7(1) of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1972.

(b) Any development which the planning authority considers to be a significant departure from the provisions of a local plan approved by the Secretary of State under section 12(4) of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1972.

For administrative purposes informal records were kept on the number of applications notified to Scottish Ministers under category 8. These are shown in the following table, however these are incomplete and we cannot separate applications relating to development or structure plan.

2000 – 24

2001 – 15

2002 – 20

2003 – 21

2004 – 3

2005 – 7

2006 – 22

Since 2009 only those applications in which authorities had an interest and that were significantly contrary to the development plan have been required to be notified to Scottish Ministers.

We do however hold some figures on the number of approvals made by planning authorities which were considered to be departures from the development plan within the period requested but not referred to Scottish Ministers. These are shown in the table below, later years can be found at the following link http://www.gov.scot/Publications/2008/01/31114430/1 .

Applications Approved as Departures from a Structure or Local Plan

 
  

2000-2001

2001-2002

2002-2003

2003-2004

  
  

Departures Advertised

Departures Approved

Departures Advertised

Departures Approved

Departures Advertised

Departures Approved

Departures Advertised

Departures Approved

Unitary Authority

  
          

Aberdeen City

35

16

34

15

20

11

23

14

Aberdeenshire

222

111

135

111

145

118

129

120

Angus

 

23

8

24

12

46

15

38

2

Argyll and Bute

156

12

207

30

173

28

27

17

Clackmannanshire

4

3

8

5

3

3

0

0

Dumfries and Galloway

58

17

45

21

20

18

0

35

Dundee City

67

29

37

27

38

24

60

25

East Ayrshire

79

37

52

39

26

38

32

21

East Dunbartonshire

9

4

0

2

8

5

0

2

East Lothian

47

2

21

1

9

0

0

7

East Renfrewshire

10

3

13

5

8

8

30

25

Edinburgh

165

77

105

105

102

98

93

58

Falkirk

 

78

8

118

14

43

5

33

0

Fife

 

30

0

28

0

17

0

30

0

Glasgow City

20

2

14

0

8

0

0

0

Highland

177

68

222

128

141

34

228

39

Inverclyde

41

13

36

17

43

15

36

8

LLTNPA

0

 

0

 

1

1

18

15

Midlothian

65

10

35

8

33

4

31

7

Moray

 

14

1

4

0

11

0

108

0

North Ayrshire

93

17

76

2

85

16

68

4

North Lanarkshire

63

22

18

12

47

24

49

30

Orkney

 

28

13

9

4

10

3

10

2

Perth and Kinross

99

30

48

23

86

28

87

35

Renfrewshire

49

2

46

2

63

1

53

2

Scottish Borders

75

0

83

0

115

0

112

1

Shetland

1

0

1

0

4

4

0

0

South Ayrshire

121

19

37

10

17

16

98

58

South Lanarkshire

82

27

90

60

134

94

132

100

Stirling

 

7

2

0

0

1

1

2

2

West Dunbartonshire

43

19

19

10

18

12

19

12

West Lothian

56

8

48

15

81

22

88

15

Western Isles

0

0

0

1

0

1

0

0

SCOTLAND

1437

580

1613

679

1556

647

1634

656

Applications advertised as departures may have been approved during a different period