Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 11 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 204 contributions

|

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

HMP and YOI Polmont

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

Neither of those scenarios is an inevitability, which is why we are taking forward those steps to address the prison population. That is a question that we, as a Parliament, will collectively need to wrestle with.

Before the summer, I set out some of the potential options for penal reform. Those were informed by the Scottish sentencing and penal commission, which is an independent commission, and its work informed the consultation that ran over the summer.

Alongside the potential steps that we are still to conclude, we are also taking steps to increase capacity. I very much recognise the projections for the prison population, not least because of the success of the justice system in prosecuting serious sexual offending, both current and historical. I will not apologise for this success, which is commanding significant custodial sentences and driving up the long-term prison population, making it the majority of the population in the Scottish Prison Service for the first time.

I say that those are not inevitabilities, but they are questions that we will need to wrestle with as a Parliament. I intend to take forward measures in due course to ensure that the Parliament can take the necessary decisions.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

HMP and YOI Polmont

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

I recognise the concerns that have been expressed, and they are part of the reason why we need to ensure that there is a stable prison population. We are taking forward steps to increase capacity through the construction of HMP Glasgow and HMP Inverness, and we are modernising the facilities that are available through the prisons that are coming on stream, looking at where further capacity can be generated and reducing the level of demand on places. We have consulted on those steps and we are currently considering that consultation. As soon as I am able, I will set out to the Parliament the steps that we will take to ensure that we provide the built environment that we need, that we reduce demand and that we are clear about who prisons are there for and what they are there to achieve.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

HMP and YOI Polmont

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

I acknowledge the substantial experience that Fulton MacGregor has as a social worker and a member of the previous Criminal Justice Committee. As I said in my answer to Jenny Young, we are looking to ensure that Polmont and other institutions are able to provide the rehabilitative support that we wish them to provide, to ensure that we have a sustainable prison population in order to allow them the space and time to do so, and also to ensure that we are investing in community justice answers. We have substantially increased Community Justice Scotland’s budget to ensure that community payback orders and other measures can be taken forward. The point that Fulton MacGregor has made about youth services is on the record and I am sure that it will have been heard in relation to the budgets that are available to other partners to deliver them.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

Winter Resilience

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

Two weeks ago, the first two named storms of the season hit Scotland. Storm Boelo, in particular, brought disruptive strong winds and rain to Scotland, causing power outages, flooding and issues across the transport network. Sadly, that also included the loss of life, and I put on the record my deepest condolences to the families and friends of those who lost their lives.

Severe weather is not a new phenomenon in Scotland and we have extensive planning and response arrangements in place, which have been tried and tested many times in recent years. However, the risk picture is changing and we must continue to keep thinking further ahead and investing in the capabilities, infrastructure and natural environment that reduce vulnerability before disruption occurs. Climate change is increasing the frequency and severity of these events, and this year’s record El Niño means that the whole of the United Kingdom is at higher risk of an unusually wet and stormy autumn and cold conditions in late winter.

The winter conditions challenges do not sit in isolation. They coincide and interact with the wider risk landscape that Scotland is facing. Geopolitical instability, hostile state activity, cyber threats, infrastructure disruption, public health pressures and supply chain vulnerabilities at home and abroad all affect Scotland and they are increasingly interconnected. That can create complex and cascading impacts that challenge traditional approaches to resilience. More than ever, we therefore need to ensure that we are prepared for the risks that we will face over the coming months and beyond.

I will therefore update Parliament on the work that we are doing to model risk and preparedness. We are working with the front-line agencies that are responsible for much of our response to emergencies and we are making strategic improvements to the resilience system to better prepare us for the challenges of the future, not just in winter but throughout the year. We are all aware that the risks that we face are changing. We are therefore updating the Scottish risk assessment, which sets out the most serious risks that we face, and we are providing the resilience community with tailored information about the impacts to enable it to be prepared.

Through the Scottish Government’s crisis preparation oversight programme, which was introduced as part of a range of improvements following the Covid pandemic, we ensure that Government preparedness arrangements, including those for winter risks, are regularly assessed, challenged and strengthened in response to evolving threats and pressures. The programme provides a structured mechanism for improving the Scottish Government’s understanding of risk, testing the adequacy of preparedness planning and driving action to address risks and strengthen mitigations.

My officials also constantly monitor shorter-term emerging risks and issues, to ensure that we know, as far as possible, what is coming our way and can therefore prepare appropriately. Through engagement with regional resilience partnerships and the Scottish resilience partnership, officials support partners to assess preparedness through their own governance arrangements, and help to identify issues that require additional support or national co-ordination.

In addition, through a number of national resilience groups that are centred around key risks and issues, we bring responders together to share learning, review guidance and build a clearer understanding of capabilities, supporting greater consistency and resilience across the system.

We also want to ensure that the public is prepared. Through our Ready Scotland website and social media channels, the Scottish Government provides clear and timely information on how to prepare for and respond to risks, events and incidents. Those can be what we know are coming, such as winter and named storms, and risks such as wildfires or worse than normal weather. Ready Scotland’s annual “Prepare for winter” social media campaign will start this month and will encourage individuals and communities to take sensible and simple steps to be ready for tough weather conditions, such as protecting pipes in homes and keeping emergency kits in cars. In addition, our targeted marketing campaign will be activated ahead of storms, to provide targeted advice to the regions that are most affected.

Together, those activities will help to build Scotland’s wider resilience by ensuring that Government, responders and the public are better equipped to anticipate, prepare for and manage the impacts of disruptive events. Experience consistently shows that reducing risks before an event occurs delivers better outcomes and value than relying on response and recovery alone.

Crucial to our preparedness for winter and other risks is our close collaboration with responders and other resilience partners. Under the Civil Contingencies Act 2004 and Scotland’s resilience framework, responsibility for preparing for, responding to and recovering from events and emergencies rests, rightly, with front-line responders and resilience partnerships, which are best placed to assess local risks, make operational decisions and co-ordinate activity on the ground. That includes not just the blue light services but local councils and health boards.

The Scottish Government’s role is not to direct that operational response but to support, co-ordinate and facilitate a shared national picture, where required, ensuring that those partners have access to the resources, information and strategic support that are needed for an effective response. That approach reflects the principle of subsidiarity, which is a cornerstone of our approach to resilience. We can all agree that incidents should be managed at the most local level, with escalation into regional or national structures only where that will add genuine co-ordination value.

That locally led, partnership-based approach ensures that decisions are taken by those with the greatest situational awareness, local knowledge, and expertise, while enabling national Government to provide oversight, assistance and escalation if circumstances demand that.

To provide such oversight, I met earlier today with the Scottish resilience partnership, bringing together the leaders of our key resilience partners, including the chair of the Scottish resilience partnership, chairs of regional resilience partnerships and strategic leaders from multiple national responder agencies and the voluntary sector. Together, we discussed early lessons that have been identified from storm Boelo, and broader winter preparedness. I also heard their strategic reflections on resilience and preparedness.

I sought assurance from responders that Scotland’s resilience arrangements remain fit for the increasingly complex risks that we face. Specifically, I challenged whether we are genuinely ready for winter, following the lessons of storm Boelo. Partners provided strong assurance that preparedness measures have been tested, exercising is taking place locally across a range of scenarios—from severe weather to defence—and the lessons that have been identified from recent events are being acted on. We will continue to engage, including through the forthcoming conference of the Scottish resilience partnership, which will focus on societal preparedness.

In a recent winter preparedness assurance process that was led by Scottish Government officials, regional and local partners reported that robust arrangements were in place for severe weather, winter maintenance, business continuity and care for people, and that those have been reviewed and refreshed ahead of winter. When we face an emergency or event that requires Government support or direction, we have robust arrangements in place.

Ahead of storm Boelo’s arrival, the First Minister activated the Scottish Government resilience room—SGoRR—which is our central co-ordination mechanism for emergencies. Regular SGoRR meetings throughout the weekend of the storm allowed ministers to receive the latest updates from the Met Office and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency. Ministers heard directly from our resilience partners, including emergency services, local councils and energy companies, and were able to ensure that they were receiving the support that they needed to manage the situation.

Our Government liaison officials worked closely with local partners, supporting them in co-ordinating their response and helping to maintain effective information flows. I know that anyone who loses power wants to be reconnected as soon as possible, and I assure them and members that responders and volunteers work hand in hand to get services back up and running as quickly as possible. I thank them all for their hard work in what were challenging circumstances.

While the response to storm Boelo demonstrated that Scotland can effectively respond to and recover from winter risks, it also generated important learning to help us and our resilience partners to improve and refine our processes at a local and national level. For example, we are already working with resilience partnerships to strengthen preparedness and assurance, including arrangements for information sharing, escalation and support to vulnerable communities during periods of disruption.

We will continue to sharpen our own response structures wherever we can, using lessons from recent incidents, including the Cairngorms wildfire and storm Boelo, with the Scottish Government resilience room working to further improve information flows with partners and across Government and ensure that ministers and senior officials continue to have early sight of emerging issues, allowing the Scottish Government to respond dynamically and effectively to fast-moving incidents of any type. Those practical improvements, which range from stronger risk assessment to greater assurance of our partners’ preparedness and building whole-of-society resilience through communications, will bolster Scotland’s resilience this winter. Together, they reflect our much wider programme to strengthen Scotland’s resilience in the face of increasingly complex, interconnected and concurrent risks.

Although the statement is focused on winter preparedness, it would be remiss of me not to acknowledge the significant Cairngorms wildfire this summer, which had a major impact on local communities and the environment. An extensive debrief process, led by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, Highland Council and Police Scotland, is under way and is expected to report in the coming weeks. We will carefully consider its findings and ensure that lessons are captured and acted on as part of our commitment to continuous improvement in Scotland’s preparedness, response and recovery arrangements.

As set out in the 2026 programme for government, we are embarking on a significant programme of work to renew and modernise the systems, structures and capabilities that support preparedness, response and recovery across the country, through the development of a Scottish resilience strategy. The strategy, developed in close consultation with our resilience partners, will help us to identify the capabilities that Scotland needs in future, understand where gaps exist and ensure that our understanding of risk informs preparedness, investment and delivery.

It will also set out our ambition for a more resilient Scotland, helping us to make the transition from a model that focuses primarily on emergency preparedness to one that strengthens resilience more broadly across our society, economy and institutions. That means ensuring that we are prepared for the decades ahead and not just next winter.

As I said at the start, Scotland faces a wide and ever-changing number of risks, which is why this Government has a range of work under way and planned. No one organisation can manage those risks alone. It is our collective duty as Government, front-line agencies, businesses and individuals to do our part in ensuring that we are able to face the challenges ahead.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

Winter Resilience

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

I very much recognise the point that Jenni Minto has put on the record, and I add my gratitude for the work of organisations such as ALIenergy and others, who provide a critical element of robustness in our communities by ensuring that community-based resilience is in play. That is a key interaction of our local resilience partnerships, where they need to be working. Part of the reason why the Scottish resilience partnership has a community and voluntary representative on it—Rob Murray from the British Red Cross—is to ensure the dynamic of community and voluntary organisations supporting individuals and our public services to have the necessary resilience in place.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

Winter Resilience

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

The budget is still to be set out—the Deputy First Minister will set it out in due course—but we have continued to provide local government with a settlement that ensures that it is capable of providing for the local resilience responsibilities. This is not about pushing down responsibility; it is about recognising the law. The Civil Contingencies Act 2004 sets out how our resilience network operates. I would be more than happy to furnish Mr Smith with more information on that, should he require it.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

HMP and YOI Polmont

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

In my statement, I set out the steps that I am seeking to take. Last week, I said to the committee that I was willing to reflect on how information is disseminated to it. I feel that I obliged in that regard from Wednesday to Tuesday, and I have now set out a potential route through which that could happen. There could be a potential protocol, or measures could be taken by the SPS, in order to disseminate information to the committee in a way that is respectful of the service’s operational independence, ensures the continued safety and safe operation of our prison system, given the complex arrangements that it manages and the risks that it holds, and allows scrutiny work to be done by the Criminal Justice Committee, for which I have the greatest respect and to which I am, of course, accountable.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

Winter Resilience

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

I very much understand the issues that Mr Findlay has raised. The examples that he gave, and other examples, were part of the discussion that I had with the Scottish resilience partnership, so that we learn lessons through the resilience network. That will enable us to ensure that there is responsiveness and that we get access to accurate information, so that local resilience partnerships can take decisions and provide a commensurate response to a particular incident. Those examples will also help to inform the forthcoming Scottish resilience framework, so that we have the necessary response in all parts of the country.

Further to my answer to Ms McNeill, the dynamic that we are facing is changing and spreading. It is not just a winter-based issue that the rural areas of the north and the islands face; the entirety of Scotland faces it, and we and the resilience partnerships must learn from the incidents that Mr Findlay has put on the record

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

Winter Resilience

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

I thank Kate Campbell for her question. From her experience in local government, she will understand where responsibility lies for the deployment of grit bins and other resilience equipment, where necessary, to ensure that communities have the necessary equipment in place to respond to weather-related incidents. I am happy to write back to Ms Campbell on the particular question about planning guidance. However, my first port of call would be to ensure that our local authority partners, by custom, deploy the necessary technology, such as grit bins, so that communities are able to respond to winter weather.

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 09:12]

HMP and YOI Polmont

Meeting date: 10 November 2026

Neil Gray

Yes. I mentioned the consultation that we ran in the summer, which followed from the recommendations of the sentencing and penal policy commission. We are wrestling with difficult choices—I understand that—and they have implications, which I also understand and recognise. However, we need to take the necessary steps to ensure that prison places are available for the most serious offenders, and we need to understand that prison is there to ensure the rehabilitation of offenders. We need to ensure that we are effectively managing individuals in the community, whether that is at the start of their interaction with the criminal justice system or as they leave prison, which the vast majority inevitably do, as well as preventing involvement in it.